The Club

Do Arsenal Have an Odegaard Problem? Are Man City ACTUALLY in Crisis and Was 2015–16 the GREATEST PL Season EVER?

The Club

Show Notes

Manchester City suffered another major setback in the title race after blowing a 2–0 lead against Tottenham on Sunday. With just one win in six in the Premier League, are City genuinely entering a crisis? After last week’s damaging 3–2 defeat to Manchester United, Arsenal responded emphatically with a 4–0 win away at Leeds to go six points clear at the top. Mikel Arteta made a bold call by starting Kai Havertz over his captain Martin Odegaard after discourse over his form and creativity. Do Arsenal have an Odegaard problem? With nostalgia around 2016 trending, the boys rewind to the 2015–16 Premier League season, the year Leicester City shocked the football world, and ask: was this the greatest Premier League season ever? And ahead of Sunday’s blockbuster Liverpool vs Manchester City, the panel builds an All-Time Liverpool & Man City Combined XI.

More from The Club

Oct 27, 2026

Adam Mckola is done with Man United, but while the pressure on Michael Carrick is at boiling point should anyone else at the club lose their job too? Him and Buvey discuss what's gone wrong and assess the list of potential candidates to replace Carrick, including Eddie Howe, Unai Emery, Julian Nagelsmann, and Antonio Conte. Rory also sits down with JCC and Miles to discuss Chelsea's historic loss to Tottenham, and the three of them grade every Premier League club's season so far!

Oct 20, 2026

Adam Mckola and Buvey are joined by Miles this week to discuss Arsenal's current performances – is their attack a cause for concern or are we overreacting? Buvey has some strong words to say about Arteta's use of Eberechi Eze. The boys also rate every single Man United signing under INEOS after Lisandro's comments calling out United's owners and Jason Wilcox – how do the likes of Mbeumo, Sesko, and Yoro fare? And finally, with the Ballon D'or coming up who makes our top fives? Why hasn't Buvey included Mbappé at all, and which Arsenal player sneaks into Miles' shortlist?

Oct 12, 2026

Adam, Rory and Buvey discuss Michael Carrick's continued struggles at Man United – how much time does he have to turn things around and would United turn to Antonio Conte? The boys also reflect on Man City's big win over Liverpool amid their ongoing rule-breaking controversy – what does it mean for Haaland, Cherki and Maresca in the long-run? We also debate football's biggest hot takes! Can Lamine Yamal become the GOAT? Is Jude Bellingham underrated? Is Kevin De Bruyne better than Steven Gerrard? And who are the most underrated players in the Premier League right now?

Oct 7, 2026

Man City fan Buvey gets grilled once again on the club's guilty charges by Adam Mckola and Rory Jennings. Has it ruined Pep's legacy, has it ruined the Premier League and is a huge points deduction even a big enough punishment? We also discuss where the likes of Haaland, Cherki and Elliot Anderson should go next if City are relegated, with rumours linking Haaland with a sensational move to Arsenal this week. The boys also play Start, Bench, Sell with a number of Premier League stars including the future of England's midfield: Kobbie Mainoo, Alex Scott and Adam Wharton. And we look ahead of a gargantuan clash between Liverpool and Man City at Anfield!

Sep 29, 2026

Following reports of Man City being found guilty of 114 charges, our resident Man City fan Buvey gives his response and debates Rory Jennings and Adam Mckola. Is there any chance of a successful appeal? And what is a worthy punishment – 100 points deduction, full on league expulsion, titles stripped?

See all episodes →