Cold Case Canada

S3 E30 Double Murder: Tanya Van Cuylenborg and Jay Cook

Cold Case Canada

Show Notes

Saanich residents Tanya Van Cuylenborg, 18 and Jay Cook, 20 were murdered while on an overnight trip to Washington State in 1987. Episode includes interviews with Detective Jim Scharf of the Snohomish Country Sheriff's Office and CeCe Moore, Chief Genetic Genealogist at Parabon Nanolabs, who cracked this case three decades later. This episode is based on a story from Cold Case BC: the stories behind the province's most sensational murders and missing persons cases Preorder my new book Beneath Dark Waters: The Legacy of the Empress of Ireland Shipwreck through Arsenal Pulp Press or our favourite bookstore - coming April 2025. For photos, show credits, sources and information about my books, blog or podcasts visit: evelazarus.comFor more information, please visit my website evelazarus.com

More from Cold Case Canada

Sep 25, 2026

On July 12, 1992, David Snow, 37 was arrested after the largest manhunt in the history of North Vancouver. His crimes spread from Ontario to British Columbia and included murders, kidnappings, robberies and sexual assaults. Last year, Snow was charged with the murder of Angelien Quesnelle from Aspley, Ontario—a case that’s been cold since 1991. For more information, visit my website: evelazarus.com or join us on the Facebook page Cold Case Canada.

Sep 11, 2026

Irene Pearson was murdered on November 15, 1979. Irene was a salesperson for Castlewood Homes and was showing a home in the Tyndall Park area of Winnipeg. During the showing she was lured to a vacant house across the street where she was hit over the head several times, and stabbed 31 times in the face and chest - one for every year of her life. Irene's body was found by two construction workers the next morning. In the early months of the investigation, Winnipeg Police had 180 people on their suspect list. For more information, please visit my website: evelazarus.com or join us on the Facebook page Cold Case Canada.

Aug 28, 2026

Twenty-year-old Melody Dobson was last seen on August 23, 1986. She was eight-and-a-half months pregnant, and at the time she went missing, she was walking home from her friend's house in South Vancouver, three blocks from her basement suite. She never made it home. For more information, please visit my website: evelazarus.com or join us on the Facebook page Cold Case Canada.

Aug 14, 2026

Dianna and Donna Ring were identical twins who grew up in North Vancouver. In 1960 the family moved to Mabel Lake in the Okanagan, the same year that 12-year-old Dianna was crowned Lynn Valley Day's May Queen. Three years later, the 15-year-olds were dead - murdered on their way home from school. Photo: Dianna (left) and Donna (right), Vancouver Sun, October 8, 1963 For more information, please visit my website: evelazarus.com or join us on the Facebook page Cold Case Canada.

Aug 7, 2026

It was a pleasure to sit down with Sgt Rob Jaberg of the Vancouver Police Department this week. We talked about his new position as supervisor and manager of the VPD’s first ever cold case team. For more information, please visit my website: evelazarus.com

See all episodes →