It Was A Sh*t Show

Contractually Obligated Casting

It Was A Sh*t Show

Show Notes

Making a movie against your will is hard. Let’s talk about how difficult it is when an actor is contractually obligated to a movie, from Emily Blunt missing out on being Black Widow to Mike Myers being a pain in The Cat In The Hat.

Get the longer Director’s Cut version of this episode on Patreon (with 8 extra minutes)!

💸 | Support us! 🔗 | Follow us! 👕 | Buy our merch!

Podcast Chapters: 00:00 - Intro 04:54 - Contractually Obligated Casting 09:38 - Ryan Reynolds in X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009) 10:00 - Jennifer Garner in Elektra (2005) 12:03 - Brad Pitt in Troy (2004) 13:30 - Emily Blunt in Gulliver's Travels (2010) 16:54 - Edward Norton in The Italian Job (2003) 22:59 - David Cross in the Alvin and the Chipmunks movies 25:07 - Bill Murray in Garfield: The Movie (2004) 28:33 - Mike Myers in The Cat in the Hat (2003) 57:58 - Bruce Willis in three movies for Disney 01:04:15 - Keanu Reeves in The Watcher (2000) 01:14:38 - Follow Ups!

Sources: ABC News CBS News Entertainment Weekly The Guardian The Howard Stern Show The Howard Stern Show IndieWire LA Times New York Times Observer Reddit SyFy Vulture

Music: Ryan Hudson - Sh*t Show Theme

#itwasashtshow #mikemyers #keanureeves Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from It Was A Sh*t Show

Sep 23, 2026

Making a godless war is hard. Let’s talk about how difficult it was to make Troy, from dealing with hurricanes and wars, to Brad Pitt enduring the most ironic injury.

Aug 26, 2026

Pleasing Darkness is hard. Let’s talk about how difficult it was to make Legend, from an entire set burning to the ground, to the multiple cuts with a completely replaced score.

Aug 19, 2026

Having great power and responsibility is hard. Let’s talk about how difficult it was to make Spider-Man, from the cheap attempts by Cannon Films, to the endless lawsuits that prevented the movie from getting made.

Jul 1, 2026

Having the power is hard. Let’s talk about how difficult it was to make Masters of the Universe, from a script that minimized Dolph Lundgren and He-Man, to Cannon Films imploding during production.

Jun 3, 2026

Making a Star War is hard. Let’s talk about how difficult it was to make Solo: A Star Wars Story, from directors Phil Lord and Chris Miller fighting with Lucasfilm, to Ron Howard replacing them.

See all episodes →