Sports Cards Nonsense

Wemby Sales After Finals Loss; Will PSA Re-Open Bulk Grading?

Sports Cards Nonsense

Show Notes

Gio opens the show by gloating just a tiny bit about being right about the Wemby market and just how cheap you can grab a Silver Prizm PSA 10 now that the Knicks won the Finals. Plus, some speculation about PSA and Chris Thomas (Ataboy Cards) stops by!

0:00 - Intro/Time to talk sports cards

2:00 - NBA Finals recap, starting with Gio gloating about the Wemby pricing

12:00 - A PSA debate about when, if ever, we see PSA open up their value and bulk tiers again for grading.

24:40 - Chris Thomas from Ataboy Cards joins the show, and they discuss his background as Gio tries to convince him to quit his job.

36:10 - What Chris is working on now and how he’s setting up leaving the teaching world.

44:45 - How Chris goes about sourcing his cards and how he focuses on what to buy

50:00 - Discussing the business of sports cards and how to maximize your time

Recording 2

1:03:45 - The correlation between Instagram followers by league and popularity in the card market.

1:09:00 - Mike’s eBay Live card show this week! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Sports Cards Nonsense

Oct 20, 2026

Ben Burrows from The Athletic joins Mike and Jesse to give us the latest on the massive theft from a FedEx truck full of PSA slabs. The latest numbers are staggering. Over orders, seven-figures worth of cards, hundreds of slabs. Stolen in broad daylight from a locked FedEx truck that was suspiciously abandoned for 90 minutes.

Oct 15, 2026

Shohei Ohtani is struggling, and the Dodgers are on the verge of elimination. How to deal with the Ohtani market crash. Plus, will we ever hear from Justin Steele again? Tough to say!

Oct 13, 2026

Mike and Jesse are joined in the studio by Shep and Mike Sterk for the first four-man booth. Mike revels in his reverse-mush working on Drake Maye. He also spent the weekend buying every Paul George rookie card he could find. Shep discusses how shops get athletes in the store. Plus, he dives into allocation and MSRP to dispel some myths. Mike has a product idea for Topps that could be a game-changer. Wrapping up with voicemails!

Oct 8, 2026

We kick off the show with Sterk's Starting Five, the five most important players left in the postseason in real-life baseball and cardboard. Gio takes a look at the MLB postseason market. Then we get into our inaugural SCN Trivia Challenge! Find out who wins. We also get an update on PSA's vault and on Mike and Jesse's charity stream on eBay Live. Wrapping up with voicemails from Mt. Rushmore.

Oct 6, 2026

Mike has company today, as Jesse is back off the IL (Gout). We get into Jason Kelce's $30k hobby adventure and how he was completely misled about the boxes he bought. Mike has a bone to pick with the shipping from Fanatics Instant Rips. Plus, how much would you need to give up a misprinted 1-of-1 card?

See all episodes →