Hidden Crime Stories

GOVERNOR LEE MAKES HIS DECISION — CHRISTa PIKE’S EXECUTION WILL PROCEED TRUE CRIME 2026

Hidden Crime Stories

Summary

Tennessee is poised to carry out its first execution of a woman in over 200 years, as Krista Pike's scheduled execution date approaches. The state has set September 30 as the date for the execution, and Governor Bill Lee has indicated that it will proceed as planned despite ongoing appeals and public outcry. Advocates for Pike argue that commuting her death sentence to life in prison without parole would acknowledge the severe childhood abuse she suffered, while still holding her accountable for her crime.

Pike, convicted of the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, has spent nearly three decades on death row, often in solitary confinement. Her legal team has raised concerns about the method of execution, citing Pike's medical conditions and the psychological impact of the execution process on a survivor of childhood trauma. They have filed a clemency petition, detailing her abusive past and mental health issues, which has garnered support from various organizations and human rights experts.

As the execution date nears, the case has drawn significant media attention, highlighting the contrasting narratives surrounding Pike and Slemmer. While some view Pike as a victim of her circumstances, others emphasize the loss experienced by Slemmer's family, who have waited decades for justice. Colleen's mother, May Martinez, plans to attend the execution, holding a photograph of her daughter to remind those present of the life lost. The situation remains fluid, with potential last-minute appeals still possible before the execution is carried out.

More from Hidden Crime Stories

See all episodes →