Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People? With Bethany Hamilton
Stay True with Madison Prewett TrouttShow Notes
This week on Stay True Podcast, Madi sits down with Bethany Hamilton for a powerful and honest conversation about suffering, faith, and the question we all ask at some point: why do bad things happen to good people? From losing her arm at just 13 years old to continuing to chase her passion for surfing, raising a family, and impacting lives around the world, Bethany opens up about what it really looks like to walk with God through the unexpected. She talks about choosing faith over fear, surrendering control, and finding purpose even when life doesn't make sense. If you've ever questioned God in the middle of hardship, struggled to understand suffering, or needed hope in a hard season, this episode will encourage you. It's a reminder that even in the hardest moments, God is still good and still working. Stay you and stay true!
Topics we dive into: -Why bad things happen and how to trust God through it -How to practically choose faith over fear -Finding purpose in pain and using your story for God's glory -What it looks like to keep going when life changes overnight AND SO MUCH MORE!
Helpful Resources: For more from Bethany Hamilton: https://bethanyhamilton.com/ Dare To Be True by Madison Prewett Troutt: https://a.co/d/gdfpHX Stay True Website: https://www.staytruepodcast.com Stay True Merch: https://www.staytruepodcast.com/merch BEAM: Visit https://shopbeam.com/STAYTRUE and use code STAYTRUE to get our exclusive discount of up to 35% off. Veracity: For up to 65% off your order, head to VeracityHealth.co and use code STAYTRUE. Home Chef: That's HomeChef.com/staytrue for 50% off your first box and free dessert for life! GCU: Visit gcu.edu to learn more.
Connect with Stay True! 💙Instagram | @staytruepodcast 💙TikTok | @staytrue_podcast 💙Follow Madison | @madiprew 💙Follow Bethany | @bethanyhamilton
More from Stay True with Madison Prewett Troutt
Welcome back to another episode of Stay True Podcast! This week, Madi sits down with Lysa TerKeurst to talk about the cost of control and how to get your peace back. When we're afraid of getting hurt, disappointed, or blindsided again, control can feel like protection… but what is it actually costing us? Madi and Lysa unpack the fears underneath our need for control, how past pain affects our ability to trust, and what it looks like to move forward through forgiveness and surrender. If you've been carrying the weight of trying to hold everything together, this conversation will encourage you to trust God with what you can't control and let His peace rule in your heart. As always, stay you and stay true!
Welcome back to another episode of Stay True Podcast! This week, Madi sits down with someone who has had a front-row seat to her entire life… HER DAD! From coaching her in basketball to hearing "Dad, I'm going on The Bachelor" and then meeting Grant, Chad Prewett shares fun memories, honest reactions, and the lessons that have shaped their relationship. Get ready for laughs, heartfelt stories, and fatherly wisdom you'll want to write down!
Welcome back to another episode of Stay True Podcast! This week, Madi sits down with John Bevere to talk about the second coming of Jesus and what it means to be ready for His return. They explore how the promise of Christ's return shapes our daily choices, calls us to live with eternity in mind, and inspires a sense of urgency to share the Gospel. This conversation invites us to examine our hearts and ask a bigger question: Are we living like we truly believe Jesus is coming back?
Welcome back to another episode of Stay True Podcast! This week, Madi sits down with Dr. Josh Axe and Dr. Will Cole to talk about caring for our bodies in a world that often leaves us stressed and exhausted. They explore what it means to treat your body as a temple, whether damage can be reversed, and how the popular health trends can become an idol. This conversation goes beyond health habits to ask a bigger question: How can we use the life God has given us to love and mentor others?
Welcome back to another episode of Stay True Podcast! In a culture that constantly tells us to love yourself, romanticize our lives, protect our peace, and put ourselves first, Jesus offers a radically different invitation: come and die, deny yourself, and serve others. In this episode, Madi is answering honest questions about comparison, insecurity, people-pleasing, pride, and self-obsession. She unpacks how to take your eyes off yourself, follow the way of Jesus, and find true freedom by living for something greater than yourself.