Making Cents

The Mortgage Advice That Fails in NZ: With Aaron Cattell (The Mortgage Man)

Making Cents

Summary

Social media platforms are flooded with mortgage tips, but many of these suggestions can lead to costly mistakes. Financial journalist Frances Cook and mortgage advisor Aaron Cattell, known as the Mortgage Man, emphasize the importance of discerning credible advice from myths circulating online. They highlight that while some tips may sound appealing, they often lack the nuance necessary for individual financial situations. For instance, the idea that one can avoid paying interest on a mortgage by making small payments daily is dismissed as unrealistic.

The conversation also delves into the ongoing debate of renting versus buying a home. Cattell argues that while owning a home may not always be the best financial decision, it can provide long-term benefits, especially as rental prices tend to increase over time. He advises potential homeowners to focus on properties where they can add value, rather than relying solely on market trends for appreciation.

Cattell further discusses the importance of understanding mortgage structures and the common pitfalls that borrowers face, such as not maximizing extra payments during fixed terms. He encourages individuals to educate themselves about their financial options and to maintain an emergency fund to avoid falling into debt traps. Ultimately, both Cook and Cattell advocate for informed decision-making in the complex landscape of home financing, urging listeners to seek personalized advice tailored to their unique circumstances.

Show Notes

Time to fact-check the mortgage advice taking over social media, and see what actually holds up. Mortgage adviser Aaron Cattell (aka The Mortgage Man) is ready to go myth-by-myth through the mortgage advice doing the rounds online, and find out what actually survives contact with someone who does this for a living. We cover: The "pay a dollar a day" trick, the viral claim that resets your mortgage interest. Weekly vs fortnightly vs monthly repayments; does paying more often actually shave years off your mortgage in New Zealand, or is that a US myth that doesn't translate? The "buy two houses, one each" couple strategy Credit scores, and how much they really matter for a NZ mortgage application Rent vs buy, and how to figure out the numbers for the NZ context

This episode of Making Cents is proudly supported by Odoo. Go to http://odoo.com/r/hpl now and try it for free, for 15 days.

Follow me everywhere! Facebook / https://www.facebook.com/FrancesCookNZ Instagram / https://www.instagram.com/francescooknz TikTok / https://www.tiktok.com/@francescooknz

Join the Money Memo newsletter for a free weekly money tip in your inbox each week https://www.francescook.co.nz/subscribe Become a confident sharemarket investor by signing up to the Market Memo newsletter https://www.francescook.co.nz/invest

#MakingCents #FrancesCook #MakingCentsPodcast #InvestingPodcast #MoneyPodcast #FinancialFreedom

Production and video editing by Lana Byrne Audio engineering by Tash Chittock Filmed by Fanaticals

More from Making Cents

Oct 29, 2026

Election day is almost here, and money is top of mind for a lot of us. In this special live edition of Making Cents, I’m joined by: Claire Matthews from Massey University Michael Gorin from EnableMe Dean Anderson, Founder and CEO of Kernel Georgia Grange, Head of NZ at Revolut

Oct 28, 2026

Do you really need $1 million to retire? Scary headlines say so, and that falling short means facing cold, miserable years ahead.

Oct 25, 2026

We grow enough food in New Zealand to feed 40 million people - eight times our own population. So why does your weekly grocery bill feel like it’s eating your entire paycheque?

Oct 22, 2026

Two years into running Making Cents as an independent business, I sit down with the TVNZ Business Breakfast team to talk about what I got right, what went wrong, and what I wish I had known before I jumped.

Oct 21, 2026

What matters more to you, money or time?

See all episodes →