DEBATE: Did Zionism Steal Judaism? | Joshua and Amalek | The Jewish God | Animals and Morality
Dilemma PodcastShow Notes
In round two with Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro, the conversation expands far beyond politics into morality, theology, identity, and the strange psychological world created by modern Zionism. We explore the deep divide between Judaism as a religious covenant and Zionism as a nationalist political project, asking whether the modern state of Israel fundamentally transformed — or even replaced — Judaism for millions of Jews in the diaspora. Along the way we discuss figures like Benjamin Netanyahu and Itamar Ben-Gvir, the rise of religious nationalism in Israel, and why some Orthodox rabbis see Zionism not as the fulfillment of Judaism but as a revolt against it.The discussion also turns surprisingly personal and philosophical. We debate veganism, eating animals, moral obligation, atheism, divine command theory, and whether morality comes from God, reason, empathy, or something deeper built into consciousness itself. Rabbi Shapiro lays out the highly legal and covenantal logic of traditional Judaism, while I push from a humanist and philosophical perspective shaped more by moral intuition and existential questions than religious law. What follows is not a hostile debate but a genuinely curious and wide-ranging exchange about free will, suffering, identity, tradition, and the uncomfortable contradictions many modern Jews feel when trying to separate Judaism from Israel.We also get into antisemitism, pro-Palestine activism, Holocaust memory, diaspora identity, and the growing confusion around what words like “Jew,” “Zionist,” and “anti-Zionist” even mean anymore. Can someone reject Zionism without rejecting Jews? Did Zionism “steal” Judaism and redefine Jewish identity around nationalism and the state? Why do so many secular Jews feel trapped inside an identity they no longer religiously believe in? And what happens when a centuries-old spiritual tradition becomes fused to military power and ethnic politics? It’s a dense, funny, provocative, and deeply philosophical conversation that moves from Talmudic reasoning to modern propaganda, from theology to vegan ethics, and from suburban American Judaism to the crisis unfolding in Israel and Palestine today.For more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com 00:00:00 Coming Up…00:01:43 Roadmap To the Conversation00:05:28 A Strange Debate About Veganism and the Jewish God00:07:53 Golda Meir’s Masada Complex00:13:25 Dear Palestine, on Jewish Pacifism and the IDF00:18:35 Amalek and Canaan00:25:40 Interpretation of Texts00:29:06 How Flexible are the Texts00:37:41 How Popular Are His Views? Can You Tell By Looking?00:47:00 The Zionists Have A Country, What Do We Have?00:53:49 The Illusion of Zionism00:59:12 Real Jews and Rabbi Shach01:03:31 Palestine or Zionism? The Moral Character of the Jewish God01:09:59 1967 and The Diaspora Jew01:13:53 Jonathan Pollard and the Diaspora Jew01:21:11 DEBATE: Is Judaism Pacifist?01:28:02 David Hume, the Is-Ought Problem, and the Uncaused Cause01:34:07 God, Perfection, and Free Will01:41:03 Child Drowning in a Shallow Pond01:47:33 Humanism, Veganism, and Human Access to the Oughts01:54:40 If the Theology is Right The Slaughterhouse Disgust is a misguided Feeling01:58:08 Rabbi’s Daughter Stopped Eating Chicken02:01:13 Feelings Versus Theology And the God Question02:06:43 Why Is There Something… Moral? And Literal Torah02:13:13 Why Does This Moral Grounding Difference Matter?02:17:26 Rabbi Calls Me Authoritarian02:18:16 Rabbi Choses Veganism All Things Being Equal02:25:07 Rabbi’s 51st State Solution Actually Ends Yaakov’s Problem02:27:53 Alex Hershaft Holocaust Survivor Turned Animal Rights Activist02:29:14 OUTRO Moral Philosophy Response - Steel manning God02:33:53 What Humanism Actually Means02:39:30 Strange Bedfellows Against Zionism
More from Dilemma Podcast
Is humanity simply a bacteria in a petri dish, heading for the inevitable edge? Do the climate markers prove it? I spoke with Professor Eliot Jacobson, a mathematician and former casino game protection expert who now spends his days tracking the most shocking climate data on the planet. From record-breaking ocean temperatures to the Earth's plummeting "albedo," we discuss the numbers that are painting a terrifying picture of our immediate future.But this conversation is about more than just graphs. It dives deep into the often misunderstood philosophy of "doomerism." What does it really mean to be a doomer? Eliot dismantles the straw-man arguments of inaction and hopelessness, instead presenting a philosophy rooted in ecological activism, grief, and a clear-eyed acceptance of our current trajectory. We explore why policy changes "ain't gonna happen" and why the goal might not be to save civilization, but to preserve what we can of the natural world.We discuss the societal "pain point" that might be needed for change, the statistical reality of our climate future, and what it means to be an activist when the odds are overwhelmingly against you. Is collapse an inevitability, or is there still time for an "anthro-shift"? Join us for a profound and honest conversation about the end of the world as we know it, and how we might learn to live with that knowledge.00:00 Coming Up...00:01:15 Intro To Eliot & Doomerism00:03:34 From Casinos To Climate00:05:13 The Charts That Eliot Shares Everyday00:10:48 Is Doomerism Hopeless or Helpless or Inactive?00:16:37 Strawmanning Doomers00:21:47 Ecological Activism00:26:08 Can Technology Save Us?00:30:01 How To Shake People Into Action00:35:31 What Is Fueling Climate Change... Population?00:40:42 What Would It Actually Take?00:47:22 Passive House, Insulate Britain, Fix Buildings00:51:11 Exponential Growth And David Suzuki00:55:43 The Great Stink? The Pain Point Is Coming?01:05:31 Should I Be A Doomer? Or Is Collapse Bad?01:11:33 Final Thoughts, David Deutsch Is Wrong And Meaninful Existential DoomerismBECOME A MEMBER - MONTHLY MEMBERS ONLY LIVESTREAM https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5NIku35U9thGG9WBJjE0sw/joinFor more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com
Radhika Desai returns to the Dilemma Podcast for a wide-ranging conversation about the state of the American left, the Democratic Socialists of America, the Marxist Unity Group, and the increasingly open discussion of socialism and communism in American politics. Is something genuinely changing in the United States—or are we simply seeing a new electoral moment inside the same old political system? As Radhika puts it, the emergence of these movements is itself evidence that the traditional two-party system is losing its ability to contain growing discontent with neoliberalism.We also get into the much bigger question: **why is capitalism in crisis, and what happens when a system can no longer deliver meaningful concessions to working people?** Radhika argues that the growing appeal of socialism has to be understood alongside the deterioration of working-class life, the financialization of capitalism, and the rise of increasingly authoritarian politics. The conversation takes us from Trump and the erosion of the old party system to fascism, anti-communism, imperialism, and the relationship between capitalist crisis and political repression.But should the left actually be excited about what is happening in America? We discuss whether the current wave represents a genuine opening for transformative politics or risks becoming a watered-down electoral version of socialism that never challenges the underlying structure of society. Radhika makes the case for taking the moment seriously—and for understanding communism not simply as a political label or historical ideology, but as a movement emerging from the contradictions of capitalism itself.00:00 Coming Up...01:32 Intro to Radhika Desai02:16 My Intellectual Path, Oct 7th, Parenti, Marx and More06:05 The History of the Left in America11:46 The Parasitical Capitalist Class13:38 What To Make of the DSA and Marxist Unity Group20:57 Rational Fascism & Capitalists28:08 Marx The 18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte32:39 Finkelstein and Corbyn Overeducated & Underemployed is Out Of Control39:18 Socialism Decays Capitalism Explodes52:21 Is the DSA Actually An Important Thing?58:22 Leftists Support Every Revolution Except The Ones That SucceedBECOME A MEMBER - MONTHLY MEMBERS ONLY LIVESTREAM https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5NIku35U9thGG9WBJjE0sw/joinFor more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com
Israeli-born artist, teacher and activist Hadas Emma Kedar joins me for a wide-ranging conversation about Zionism, Israel, Germany, the IDF, and the possibility of a radically different future. Hadas grew up inside Zionist culture and gradually came to see the ideology she had inherited as morally indefensible. We talk about that transformation, her experiences as an anti-Zionist activist, the particular German obsession with Jews and Israel, the anti-German movement, and what she sees as the depravity of the Israeli military and the society that sustains it.We also talk about what a future beyond Zionism might actually look like, what would have to change for Israelis and Palestinians to escape the present system, and whether such a transformation is possible. Hadas also discusses her new performance piece, Together We Lose, which draws on her own experiences and explores the emotional and political realities behind the subjects we discuss. This is a long, personal conversation about ideology, identity, guilt, violence, art, and the possibility of something different.00:00:00 Coming Up...00:01:28 Intro to Hadas00:03:06 From the Galalie00:16:14 What Kind of Zionism Was It?00:20:27 Are We Always Talking To Our Haters?00:31:21 Going Elsewhere... Not Israel00:40:01 Breaking The Silence?00:47:54 Hadas's Art And What Happened In Israel00:54:50 The Conversation Across the Wall?01:01:52 A Zoom Call On October 8th01:07:43 Humans Do Evil Things. Monsters Don't Exist.01:26:31 The Out Group Of "Jewish Nationality"01:38:03 What's Up In Germany?01:51:36 The Anit-Deutsch01:56:22 Fascism Is Capitalism In Crisis02:03:09 "Together We Lose" Hadas's New ArtBECOME A MEMBER - MONTHLY MEMBERS ONLY LIVESTREAM https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5NIku35U9thGG9WBJjE0sw/joinFor more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com
Daniel Klein was born and raised in Efrat, one of the largest religious Zionist settlements in the occupied West Bank. His family helped build the settlement movement, and he grew up immersed in its schools, institutions, theology, politics, and culture before serving as an IDF tank commander. In this conversation, Daniel shares an insider's account of life inside the religious Zionist world, the psychology of belief, the realities of the settlement project, and how Zionism can present a different face to different people while maintaining a powerful hold over identity and belonging.We discuss Efrat, the West Bank, violent settlers, the relationship between Judaism and Zionism, the dehumanization of Palestinians, military service, nationalism, religious identity, cognitive dissonance, moral injury, and the personal costs of dissent. Daniel explains why leaving Zionism can mean losing family, friends, community, status, and purpose. He describes the process by which ideological systems reproduce themselves, how Israelis are taught to understand Palestinians, and why so many people remain trapped inside narratives.We also explore Daniel's awakening during COVID, what caused his worldview to unravel, why he believes Israeli society is entering a period of profound crisis, and what lessons his journey offers for all of us.00:00:00 Coming Up...00:01:44 Three Big Announcements00:04:44 Introducing Daniel & Centering Jewish Trauma00:09:26 Growing Up in Efrat00:12:07 Who Are Settlers?00:15:02 Zionist Schools Are Crazy00:20:53 Zionism Meets You Where You're At00:23:34 When Daniel Visited Auschwitz00:26:57 Israelis Were Celebrities To Me00:35:22 Supporting Israel Except The Settlers00:42:12 The Intellectual And Emotional Crack00:50:23 It Happens Quickly, During COVID01:02:30 Free Fall Collapse Of Israel01:09:47 A Smiling Grandmother With a Sweater01:19:44 The Violent Supernova At The EndBECOME A MEMBER - MONTHLY MEMBERS ONLY LIVESTREAM https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5NIku35U9thGG9WBJjE0sw/joinFor more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com
In this conversation with geopolitical scholar Mia Bennett, we explore why the Arctic is no longer a frozen periphery but the front line of global power. From Vladimir Putin planting a Russian flag beneath the North Pole seabed to renewed nuclear tensions across the polar region, the Arctic has become a stage for military posturing, resource competition, and great-power rivalry. As climate change rapidly melts sea ice, new shipping routes open and vast reserves of oil, gas, and critical minerals become accessible — intensifying what some call a new era of frontier capitalism. We discuss the long history of colonization in the far north, the strategic obsession with places like Greenland (including Donald Trump’s attempt to purchase it), and the often-overlooked role of Indigenous Arctic peoples navigating sovereignty, survival, and self-determination amid global ambition. The Arctic is a “cold canary in the coal mine” — revealing how environmental collapse, geopolitical rivalry, and extractive economics converge at the top of the world. What happens there will shape the century ahead.00:00 Coming Up01:18 Intro (Epstein News cycle )05:13 Mia's Path to the North07:51 Where is the Arctic?16:48 The Very Crowded Arctic20:59 The Cold Canary24:25 Why Does Trump Want Greenland?26:45 Colonialization of the Arctic30:58 Who Would Fight?33:01 Frontier Capitalism37:21 Global Warming and Getting Attention in the Arctic41:20 Taking Greenland Who Fights Back?44:11 A Story about Space and the Arctic46:58 Who Owns Space?50:39 Trusting Russia and the Arctic53:56 The Broken Global Order and the Arctic59:53 Does WW3 Start in the Arctic?BECOME A MEMBER - MONTHLY MEMBERS ONLY LIVESTREAM https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5NIku35U9thGG9WBJjE0sw/joinFor more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com