Back from the Borderline

The Arrogance of Too Much Empathy

Back from the Borderline

Show Notes

This might be the most personally confronting episode I’ve recorded in a long time.

A few days ago, I had to send a text message I had been absolutely dreading. I spent days worrying about how this person would feel, what they would think, whether they’d be hurt, disappointed, blindsided, angry, or quietly resentful.

Then the moment came when I needed to send the damn text already. So I did. And guess what? Their response completely dismantled the story I had been telling myself all week. That experience led me into a much bigger question: at what point does empathy stop being empathy and start becoming an attempt to manage someone else’s reality for them?

The deeper I looked, the more I saw how often I move through life assuming responsibility for experiences that do not actually belong to me. And I doubt I’m alone in that. Maybe this is something you’re doing without realizing it, too.

In this episode, we talk about over-responsibility, people-pleasing, parenting, Rudolf Steiner, Dion Fortune, Martin Buber, the Christian mysteries, and why trusting another person’s capacity might be one of the deepest forms of love there is.

Along the way we explore:

• Why highly sensitive people often become emotional managers • The hidden arrogance inside over-empathy • The difference between caring for someone and carrying them • Why rescuing can quietly undermine growth • What parenting teaches us about trust • The spiritual danger of trying to live other people’s lives for them • The relationship between love, faith, and control • How to stop rehearsing other people’s suffering

Reflection questions from this episode (for your journal, MOODS, or simply a conversation with yourself):

• What do I actually know? • What am I assuming? • What part of this belongs to me? • What would respect look like here? • Am I helping this person, or am I trying to protect myself from the discomfort of watching them have their own experience? • What resources might this person have that I cannot see?

These questions ended up changing the entire direction of my thinking. If you spend some real time with them, I think they might do the same for you.

CONTINUE THE WORK: Join the BFTB Patreon → https://patreon.com/backfromtheborderline

You’ll get: ☆ Weekly bonus episodes ☆ Consciousness Stream ☆ Archetypal tarot + astrology forecasts ☆ Full ad-free archive access (every BFTB episode since 2021)

If you want to actually work through it: Use MOODS → https://app.moods.world/ MOODS is a private place to take what’s coming up and see it clearly without performing it or involving anyone else. You can try it free for 7 days to see if it's right for you. If you join my Patreon first, you’ll also unlock discounted access. See you inside. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

More from Back from the Borderline

Oct 20, 2026

For seven conversations, Anne Baring and I have been investigating the forgotten feminine face of God. We’ve explored Sophia, Mary Magdalene, the Grail, and the religious traditions that preserved aspects of the sacred feminine. Now, in our eighth and final conversation, we’re asking what all of that knowledge is supposed to do to us.

Oct 13, 2026

In medieval southern France, a woman stood up during a religious debate and challenged the men who claimed the authority to speak for God. A Catholic cleric told her to return to her spinning, because theology was no business of hers. Her identity was Esclarmonde de Foix, and she belonged to a Christian religious culture in which women could teach, exercise spiritual authority and administer sacred rites.

Oct 6, 2026

A spiritual teacher dies, her community has to continue without her, and centuries later the written record can no longer tell us exactly how her teachings moved from one generation to the next. What, if anything, survives?

Sep 29, 2026

Mary Magdalene has spent nearly two thousand years buried under other people’s interpretations of her. Repentant prostitute. Devoted disciple. Apostle to the apostles. Mystic. Wife of Jesus. Suppressed leader of early Christianity. This episode asks us to actually meet Miriam before deciding who she was.

Sep 22, 2026

What kind of spiritual world could have formed Yeshua before Christianity existed?

See all episodes →