Show Notes
Criticism and rejection in art can feel a lot like passing a kidney stone—sharp, painful, and definitely not something you want to experience. In this episode, we're diving deep into this rather unique analogy, exploring how those pesky critiques can actually help us grow stronger, just like surviving a kidney stone ordeal. I'll share my personal adventures with these little buggers and how they’ve surprisingly mirrored my creative journey. We’ll also chat about the importance of separating ourselves from our work, because let’s be honest, nobody wants to be called ugly—especially not our artistic babies! So grab a comfy seat, maybe a glass of water (hydration is key, folks!), and let’s tackle the ups and downs of artistic rejection together. Dealing with Criticism and Rejection Welcome back to The New Artist’s Compass. Today we’re getting real about criticism and rejection. Both are as natural in the creative process as kidney stones are in life—painful, unwelcome, but sometimes unavoidable. And just like I recently had to pass one of those tiny nightmares, dealing with rejection can leave you doubled over, questioning your choices, and wondering why the universe insists on testing your endurance. Here’s the thing: rejection isn’t a verdict on your worth as an artist. It’s a kidney stone—sharp, unexpected, and it feels huge in the moment, but in the grand scheme of things, it’s tiny. Painful, yes. Life-ending? Not even close. The Kidney Stone Metaphor Criticism can feel sharp and painful, but like a kidney stone, it eventually passes. You’re not defined by the pain, but by how you handle it.
Separating Self from Work Rejection of your art isn’t rejection of you. Learning to detach helps keep creativity flowing.
Constructive vs. Destructive Feedback Not all criticism is created equal. How to spot the difference and use what actually helps.
Resilience as a Creative Muscle Every “no” or negative review is a rep in building creative strength. Over time, rejection becomes less personal and more fuel
Finding Humor in the Hurt Using levity (like the kidney stone tie-in) to diffuse the sting. Humor makes space for growth and healing.
Topics covered in this series Sharing Your Work Online for the First Time Dealing With Criticism and Rejection Finding (or Building) an Artistic Community Collaboration as a Creative Catalyst Staying Motivated Long-Term Art Challenges & Social Media Trends Mental Health & Creativity Art Challenges & Social Media Trends Setting Up a Creative Workspace Creative Constraints & Prompts Measuring Growth as an Artist Why Do You Create? When to Call Yourself an Artist Lessons From a Year of Creating Setting Creative Goals Without Killing the Joy Takeaways: Criticism and rejection are like kidney stones: painful, sharp, and inevitable, but they pass! Just like dealing with a kidney stone, facing criticism helps us emerge stronger and wiser in our creative journey. It's crucial to separate yourself from your work; the critique is about your piece, not you as a person. Analyzing feedback can be beneficial; it’s like examining a kidney stone to prevent future ones from forming! Embrace criticism with humor, because getting through it only makes your future work even better! When faced with rejection, remember: it's not about you, it's about the art you create, so keep creating!
Links referenced in this episode: createartpodcast.com findapodcastabout.xyz tkbpodcaststudio.com
How do I get such great guests? PodMatch I use Podmatch to get the best guests on the show. Check out PodMatch if you want to guest on other podcasts or if you have a podcast and need guests for your show. Guests from Podmatch Make Sharing your podcast easier Use Podcast Beacon for the best NFS products to share your podcast while out and about or at conferences.
Reach Out To The Podcast To reach out to me, email [email protected] I would love to hear about your journey and what you are working on. I
More from Create Art Podcast
Description: Failure isn't a dead end—it's raw data. In Episode 2 of The Sustainable Shift, we unpack why creators freeze up when things don't go according to plan and how to reframe missteps as essential feedback rather than a verdict on your worth. Plus, we check in on listener submissions for the "One Project" challenge. In this episode: Why the fear of failure is the number one cause of unfinished work. Shifting your mindset from "failure as a flaw" to "failure as intelligence." How to build a resilient creative practice that survives missed marks. Real listener updates from the "One Project" challenge.
I'm moving the Rough Sketch show to once a month because life (clients, interviews, and general chaos) is loud, and I'm using that extra space to go back to poetry — the thing that actually hooked me on art. I'm Timothy Kimo Brien, your resident instigator, and this episode is me dusting off 12 steno pads, putting pen to paper, and reading a rough sketch called "Going Back" that leans on jazz, nostalgia, and the messy, beautiful return to simplicity. The poem walks through late-night weariness, a mausoleum of depression, and the small ritual of scratching thoughts down as both warning and salvation — basically me trying to send postcards to myself from places I shouldn't have left. I talk about why prompts didn't stick, how I decided no prompt was needed, and why editing in a new way helped the work breathe. Stick around for the pieces I read, give me your honest take, and take this as your friendly nudge to tame that inner critic: create more than you consume, write a poem about what you're going through, and maybe share it with me. I'll catch you next month — same chaos, more poems. Poem: Going Back 6 Sept 2026
As October arrives, nature enters a deliberate cycle of rest and preparation—yet human creators often respond with end-of-year panic and frantic hustle. In the premiere episode of The Sustainable Shift, Timothy makes the case for The Slow Season. Discover why stepping back from relentless output isn't quitting, but rather essential infrastructure for long-term, sustainable creativity. Plus, an update on the "One Project" challenge and how you can join in. In this episode: Why October is the ideal month to reject end-of-year pressure and embrace quiet focus. The danger of treating creativity like a factory floor that never closes for maintenance. How to build creative boundaries that protect your energy and prevent burnout. An invitation to commit to your "One Project" for the rest of the year.
In the final episode of Create Anyway: You’re Allowed to Make Art, we explore a powerful question that many artists avoid: What if what you’ve done is already enough? Throughout this series, we’ve talked about fear, identity, time, responsibility, and creative pressure. But at the center of all of it is a deeper tension — the belief that we are always behind, always lacking, always needing more before our work “counts.” This episode challenges that belief. If you’ve ever felt like: You’re not good enough yet You started too late You should be further along Your work doesn’t measure up
We live in a world that screams for more—more output, more hustle, and more noise. But the most enduring work isn't born from the noise; it’s born from the quiet. In this special trailer episode, Timothy introduces the upcoming season of the Create Art Podcast: The Sustainable Shift. Starting this October, we are moving away from the "more-is-better" mindset. Instead, we’re focusing on Sustainable Creativity—finding a way to create that lasts as long as you do. We’ll be exploring the necessity of Reframing Failure as valuable data, and we are launching the "One Project" challenge: a call to commit to just one creative goal, free from the pressures of monetization or public performance. If you’re ready to protect your energy, reclaim your practice, and create more than you consume, join us for the new season starting in October 2026. In this episode: The mission behind The Sustainable Shift season. Why we are moving beyond "hustle culture" to prioritize long-term, sustainable craft. An introduction to the "One Project" challenge and how you can participate.