Show Notes
In this episode of the podcast I had the pleasure of chatting with Donna Jackson for the Coaching with Integrity Podcast.
In this episode, we're talking about one of the most misunderstood clients in the fitness industry: the chronic yo-yo dieter. The person who knows exactly what to do, has done it before, and somehow ends up back at square one. Again. We dig into why labelling these clients as lacking discipline is not only wrong — it's actively making things worse. Years of dieting leave a mark, not just physically but psychologically, and coaching them the same way you'd coach a first-timer is a recipe for another rebound. We cover: Why adherence failure is a coaching problem, not a client problem The emotional and behavioural patterns that keep chronic dieters stuck What the first 30 days with these clients should actually look like The dietary approaches most likely to backfire — and what to do instead Why maintenance is a skill set coaches need to actively teach How to build client autonomy so they don't need you forever If you want help breaking away from yo-yo dieting
Apply for coaching here www.shanewalshfitness.com/onlinecoaching
More from The Shane Walsh Podcast
At 53, after 30 years of dieting, Marie said, "I don't know who I am if I'm not trying to lose weight." In this episode, Shane Walsh explains how yo-yo dieting hardens into an identity, why the shame around emotional eating is the real problem and not the eating itself, and how to question the stories you've been carrying. You'll hear Marie's story of tracing each label back to where it came from, rewriting it, and finally closing the chapter. This is episode 6 in the countdown to the launch of Break Free, out on Nov 3rd pre order now https://shorturl.at/NkbpN
Rachel spent 26 years using self-criticism as her motivation, and she was terrified that without it she'd give up. In this episode, Shane Walsh unpacks the Shame-Sabotage Loop, the cycle where body shame triggers a diet, a slip, more shame, and a binge. He explains why compassion isn't complacency, and why body neutrality is a realistic middle ground between hating and loving your body. You'll hear Rachel's story, and two simple daily practices you can try today: the Best Friend Test, and unfollowing and curating what you see online.
Tara weighed herself every morning for five years, and most of the swings she cried over turned out to be water. In this episode, Shane Walsh explains how daily weigh-ins can fuel the yo-yo cycle, what really moves the number on the scale, and how to detach emotionally from it with practical tools from the book. This is episode 4 in the countdown to the launch of Break Free, out on Nov 3rd
Sarah was perfect Monday to Friday and in total rebellion on the weekend, and she did it for over a decade. In this episode, Shane Walsh explains all-or-nothing thinking, shows the eight-week maths that makes the case for 80/20 over perfection, and introduces "imperfect action" as the middle ground where lasting change lives. This is episode 3 in the countdown to the launch of Break Free, out on Nov 3rd
Annemarie yo-yo dieted for 17 years, and the foods she "snapped" on were always the ones she'd banned. In this episode, Shane Walsh explains the deprivation-binge cycle, why labelling foods "good" and "bad" keeps you stuck, and the Permission Paradox: why giving yourself full permission to eat all foods can reduce overeating. This is episode 2 in the countdown to the launch of Break Free, out on Nov 3rd