Francesca Rudkin: What does livestreaming an execution actually achieve?
The Sunday Session with Francesca RudkinShow Notes
There are some crimes so horrendous that finding the right words to describe them is almost impossible. The 2009 Fort Hood shooting in Texas, in which Nidal Hasan killed 13 people and wounded 32 others, is one of them. Hasan was convicted and sentenced to death. Now, US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth says his execution by firing squad, scheduled for December 3, will be livestreamed so the public can watch. The reasoning, apparently, is that people need to understand there are serious consequences for crimes like this. Really? I think we already understand. There can be no argument about the enormity of what Hasan did, or the devastation inflicted on the victims, their families and colleagues. The justice system has imposed its ultimate penalty. But why do we need to watch? What does livestreaming an execution actually achieve? Is it about transparency? Or has the business of justice, or vengeance, become a performance, with the execution the grand finale, the final episode? I have never watched a beheading. I have never watched footage of the Christchurch mosque massacre. I have never deliberately sought out videos of people being killed. Not because I don't want to understand the horror of these events, but because I don't believe watching somebody die helps me understand it any better. It also feels disrespectful to the victims. Their horror turned into a curiosity. We’re already surrounded by images of violence. The internet has made it possible to witness the very worst of humanity, often within seconds of it happening. But just because something can be broadcast doesn't mean it should be, and we could be subjected to it even if we choose not to watch. There is a reason public executions have largely disappeared from modern society. It’s believed this would be the first public execution in the US in almost a century. Legally there may be issues as to whether it can be broadcast. But there’s no doubt that reducing someone's death to a spectacle risks reducing a serious judicial act to entertainment, outrage or political messaging. And it raises an uncomfortable question: what separates this from the public executions associated with countries such as Iran, or the Taliban in Afghanistan? This places the United States in dubious company. Will watching an execution deter crime? People continue to commit crimes knowing they could be put to death for them. Does it help victims' families? I can’t say. But this feels less about deterrence, and more about asserting control, projecting power and scoring political points. We can understand the severity of a crime without watching someone die. We can support justice without turning death into a show. A healthy society is measured not by what it is able to broadcast, but by what it chooses to leave unwatched. JD Vance has said that if the livestream of the execution goes ahead, he won’t be watching it. For once, there’s something we agree on. LISTEN ABOVE See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
More from The Sunday Session with Francesca Rudkin
Irish actor Ciaran Hinds has spent five decades in the film industry, including distinctive roles in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, There Will Be Blood, Munich and Game of Thrones. His latest project, The Three Urns, will be available for Kiwi audiences too check out soon - as part of the upcoming British and Irish Film Festival. He says the film follows the story of a man on a mission, but there's some extra details that won't surface until the end. LISTEN ABOVE See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Taika Waititi is well-regarded as one of New Zealand's most successful directors - and he's got a new project in the works. He's known for directing films like Thor: Ragnarok, Jojo Rabbit, Boy, Hunt for the Wilderpeople and What We Do in the Shadows, but the new sci-fi film Klara and the Sun promises to show fans a different experience. He says he didn't feel the need to 'Taika' this project up too much, and add as many jokes as he's used to using. "Cause it's a really beautiful story, it's kind of bittersweet as well, and I want to retain all that and not make it a super silly film." LISTEN ABOVE See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Adam & Eve by Jeffrey Archer. Sadly, this is his last work of fiction but is a great way to end an extraordinary career. Many readers will recall Kane & Abel which is considered by many to be amongst his finest work - and lovers of that will love this one. It begins on Armistice Day, 1918, when two very different children are born. One is the daughter of an Earl, the other the son of a shepherd who works on the Earl's estate. Despite their different circumstances they form an extraordinary bond and on a September night in 1940 as Hitler prepares to invade Britain, their actions will change his mind. Inter Alia by Suzie Miller. She wrote a wonderful play, and novel, called Prima Facie which was a legal story as is this. Jessica is a judge in London. Her husband resents that she’s been appointed to the bench when he hasn’t, and hey have a teenage son with social issues about whom they worry. They’re thrilled when he’s invited to a party, but things don’t go as planned and in the weeks and months afterwards, Jessica has to juggle the competing pressure of being a mother, an advocate for her child, a wife, a friend and a judge. As with Prima Facie it’s very well done - terrific storytelling with a moral dilemma at its heart. LISTEN ABOVE See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Travel expert Megan Singleton's on her latest adventure to Hawaii, and she's noticed it's still busy in the off-season. She took a look at the Pearl Harbour memorial ahead of the infamous bombing's 85th anniversary, and experienced a sunset harbour cruise. LISTEN ABOVE See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
This week on the Sunday Panel, journalist and editor, Jo McCarroll, and Director at 818, Chris Henry, joined in on a discussion about the following issues of the day - and more! Do we know who we're going to vote for yet? Early voting opens next week - are we ready for it? What do we need to see in the coming days? The Taxpayers' Union recently released a controversial attack ad directed at Labour - and made with AI. Do we think this is fair campaigning? What's with the supermarket chicken bags being sold on eBay? LISTEN ABOVE See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.