Show Notes
Casimir Sucharsky Jr. — or Butch Casey, as he's known — is the flashy, well-known owner of the popular South Florida nightclub Casey's Nickelodeon. After a night out at his bar in June 1994, he invites two young, attractive women back to his house for an after-hours party. As they share a bottle of wine, two intruders with a machine gun burst into the house and slay all three. Police discover the crime has been caught on a remarkable, 22-minute surveillance video. What they see on the tape is brutal and terrifying — and sets investigators on a frantic chase for suspects. Subscribe today so you don't miss an episode. Visit FeloniousFlorida.com.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
More from Felonious Florida
Doubts about George Altidor's alibi can't stop the case from going cold. But when a young detective reopens the investigation, he uncovers a stunning revelation about George's new life. As the grieving family of Theresia, Marie, Samantha, and Sabrina pushes for justice, the question remains: Will the truth ever be uncovered? PHOTOS AND VIDEOS You can view photos and videos from the case file and archives online by visiting FeloniousFlorida.com and finding photo links for each episode. SOCIAL MEDIA Follow us on social media for additional information and updates on the Altidor case and previous case Felonious Florida has told. Facebook | X | Instagram | Bluesky
A chilling message scrawled on a wall of the Altidor home becomes the key clue in the case — not for what it says, but for its secrets that science may be able to unlock. Disturbing details from George's past begin to surface. Detectives discover a mysterious phone call from inside the Altidor house on the day of the murders that grinds the investigation to a frustrating halt. PHOTOS AND VIDEOS You can view photos and videos from the case file and archives online by visiting FeloniousFlorida.com and finding photo links for each episode. SOCIAL MEDIA Follow us on social media for additional information and updates on the Altidor case and previous case Felonious Florida has told. Facebook | X | Instagram | Bluesky
Small clues at the crime scene could lead to a breakthrough in the case. The autopsies of Marie, Theresia, Samantha, and Sabrina raise serious questions about George Altidor's alibi that he was at work at the time of the murders. As detectives close in, George submits to a lie detector test and the shocking results lead to a major shift in the investigation. PHOTOS AND VIDEOS You can view photos and videos from the case file and archives online by visiting FeloniousFlorida.com and finding photo links for each episode. SOCIAL MEDIA Follow us on social media for additional information and updates on the Altidor case and previous case Felonious Florida has told. Facebook | X | Instagram | Bluesky See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
As detectives piece together the events of the Altidor murders, they are struck by the brutality and chilling efficiency of the killer. In a matter of seconds, each victim was eliminated. The few clues left behind seem intentionally designed to mislead investigators into thinking the attack was a home invasion. But detectives aren't so easily fooled and suspect the murders were personal. PHOTOS AND VIDEOS You can view photos and videos from the case file and archives online by visiting FeloniousFlorida.com and finding photo links for each episode. SOCIAL MEDIA Follow us on social media for additional information and updates on the Altidor case and previous case Felonious Florida has told. Facebook | X | Instagram | Bluesky
From a rural mountain village in Haiti to the sun-soaked streets of South Florida, Marie Laverne chases the promise of a better life. A chance encounter with a man from her past, George Altidor, leads to marriage and a picture-perfect family. But beneath the surface, something was not right. In the months leading up to her murder, friends and family noticed unsettling changes in Marie — signs of fear, distress, and secrets she never got the chance to share. PHOTOS AND VIDEOS You can view photos and videos from the case file and archives online by visiting FeloniousFlorida.com and finding photo links for each episode. SOCIAL MEDIA Follow us on social media for additional information and updates on the Altidor case and previous case Felonious Florida has told. Facebook | X | Instagram | Bluesky