804 - The Truth About Big Bucks, Genetics & Deer Management | Lindsay Thomas Jr.
The Southern Outdoorsmen Hunting PodcastShow Notes
What actually creates bigger bucks? Is it genetics, nutrition, habitat, or something else entirely? In this episode, National Deer Association’s Lindsay Thomas Jr. separates decades of deer research from hunting folklore. We dive into the biggest myths surrounding deer management, aging bucks on the hoof, habitat improvement, feral hogs, and the science that has fundamentally changed how we understand whitetails. If you’re serious about becoming a better deer hunter or land manager, this episode is packed with practical, research-backed information you can apply immediately. Topics discussed: Why genetics matter far less than most hunters think The Mississippi State study that changed how we view big bucks How to accurately age bucks on the hoof Common mistakes hunters make when managing deer Why cull buck programs don’t improve genetics The truth about nutrition, habitat, and antler growth How to improve a property—even if it’s small Food plots vs. timber management: where to invest your effort How hunting pressure influences mature buck movement The four biggest factors that actually affect deer movement Why feral hogs are so damaging to deer and turkey populations Why trapping is far more effective than simply shooting hogs How to work with neighbors to improve deer quality across a landscape Lessons from over two decades of deer research and management
Join our Circle Community here - https://the-southern-outdoorsmen.circle.so/checkout/join-the-community
Our Sponsors: * Check out MyBookie and use my code SOUTHERNOUTDOORSMEN for a great deal: https://www.mybookie.ag * Check out TruDiagnostic and use my code SOUTHERNOUTDOORSMEN for a great deal: https://www.trudiagnostic.com
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
More from The Southern Outdoorsmen Hunting Podcast
Kyle had gone almost 20 years without killing a mature buck with a bow. Then, on Alabama's opening weekend, he jumped one out of his bed at 12 yards in an old cattle catch pen. Instead of leaving, he sat down in the grass, and the buck came back 15 minutes later. With Jacob on his honeymoon, Kyle and Thomas Myers join Andrew to break down that hunt, how to hunt a Black Belt cattle farm, and your questions. In this episode: - Hurricane knocked green acorns to the ground: will deer still eat them? - What can you learn from seeing deer at night? - HOT TAKE: bow shots past 60 yards aren't bowhunting - 20 years of bowhunting without a mature buck, and why - The shooter buck Jacob missed for his wedding - A cold front at the wedding and why Kyle had to go - Slipping into an old catch pen on a high-wind day - Jumping a bedded buck at 12 yards - Overhead cover when you're set up on the ground - Why less gear makes you a better woodsman - Moving through cover: shade, shadows, and stopping every few steps - How a Black Belt cattle farm lays out - Do cattle ruin your deer hunting? - Why bucks on a farm live on 15 to 40 acres - Will a buck come back to a bed you bumped him from? - Hunting pastures like Midwest funnels - The trail camera that missed three giants - When white oaks aren't dropping: mountain chestnut oaks and water oaks
Tim Knight put the rifle down for good in 1985, and he killed most of the bucks on his wall the same way: rattling from a climber with his antlers on the ground. We sat down in Tim's trophy room in Georgia to get into his yo-yo rattling method, why he wants to sound like two small bucks sparring instead of a buck fight, and why his favorite week to rattle comes before the does are ready.
In this listener Q&A, we walk through a day of post-hurricane scouting: six and a half miles of acorns on the ground and only one spot worth hunting, plus the three-reason test that made the call. Then we run through your questions, hot takes, and some Circle marriage advice before Jacob ties the knot.
Asher Kight found a mature buck in his bed in late summer, filmed him from 20 yards, then set up 184 yards away and killed him early season. We get into how Asher finds and targets individual mature bucks in the Arkansas mountains, why he scouts far more than he hunts, and how he plans to kill a target buck in four sits or less. In this episode:
In this listener Q&A, we get into whether your wind actually pushes a buck out of his bed, or whether it's the walking in that does it. Then we run through your questions, hot takes, and hot tips as Alabama's opener closes in.