How She Does It

EP 61: Renée Elise Goldsberry: Everything, All At Once

How She Does It

Show Notes

It was the role of a lifetime: Angelica Schuyler in the Broadway phenomenon “Hamilton.” But Renée Elise Goldsberry turned down the audition. Not just once, but multiple times.

As she explains to Karen Finerman in this episode and in her new documentary “Satisfied,” it was at that same moment that the family Renée had fought so hard to create was finally coming together. She and husband Alexis had just brought home their daughter Brielle, adopted from Ethiopia. She joined big brother Benjamin to make their family of four. After years of infertility struggles, Renée was ready to spend her energy being a mom to her very young children.

That was her plan, until her manager implored her to at least listen to the music from what was then called “The Hamilton Mixtape.” In the moment that she first heard Lin-Manuel Miranda singing the demo for “Satisfied,” she knew she wanted the part. She got it, and the rest is Broadway history.

Renée’s versatility as a singer and actress has served her well since then: she starred in the musical comedy series “Girls5Eva” and can now be seen in Oscar-winner Kathryn Bigelow’s new film “A House of Dynamite” on Netflix. In it, she plays the first lady as the president, played by Idris Elba, is facing a nuclear crisis.

💬 In this episode, we explore:

Renée’s memories of “Hamilton” from its workshop days to its recent 10th anniversary celebration

How Renée managed the demands of a mega-hit Broadway musical while raising young children

Behind the scenes of her new documentary "Satisfied,' and how fellow actresses Kelli O’Hara and Audra McDonald supported her

Why her new album “Who I Really Am” is her most personal work yet

How Renée knew her husband Alexis Johnson was the right one for her

The role faith has played in both Renée’s personal and professional life

The good advice her “Girls5Eva” co-star Paula Pell gave her about managing anxiety

The coveted birthday present Renée gives to her friends and family

And the exciting text John Mulaney sent Renée and her fellow castmates of “Documentary Now! Original Cast Album: Co-Op”

🔗 Visit Renée Elise Goldsberry’s website

🔗 For Information on the SATISFIED Documentary

🔗 For information on Netflix’s A HOUSE OF DYNAMITE

🎧 Listen To Renee’s New Album, Who I Really Am

📸 Follow Renée Elise Goldsberry on Instagram

📸 Follow Renée Elise Goldsberry on TikTok

📸 Follow the show on Instagram: @hsdipodcast

🎧 New episodes of How She Does It drop every Tuesday. Be sure to follow us so you never miss an episode Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from How She Does It

Jul 21, 2026

How She Does It is on a short hiatus, but Karen was kind enough to let us drop into your feed today. This show is part of the HerMoney Media Network — so if you like what you hear, come find us at The HerMoney Podcast.

Jun 30, 2026

What motivates some of today’s successful leaders? What person or event helped snap their futures into focus, creating a roadmap they followed with grit and resilience, determined to make it to the highest levels in business and beyond?

Jun 16, 2026

Imagine willingly opening up your life to as much A.I. as possible. Have a question? Ask A.I. first. Feeling blue? Talk to an A.I. therapist. Need a ride? Summon a Waymo. In journalist Joanna Stern’s New York Times bestseller “I Am Not a Robot: My Year Using AI to Do (Almost) Everything,” she did all of the above and more. She shares what's hopeful, what’s creepy, and how A.I. is already in your life, whether you like it or not.

Jun 9, 2026

In our first-ever pop-up podcast in front of a live audience, Karen Finerman sits down with Karen Firestone at the CNBC Pro Event: Wealth For Women at the Nasdaq MarketSite. Karen Firestone, who goes by Kari, began building her impressive career as an investor in the early ‘80s. There were far fewer women working in finance at that time, and things were far more challenging for women in that space than they are today. Still, Kari couldn’t have imagined taking a different path.

Jun 2, 2026

What does it take to create culture-defining entertainment that not only attracts loyal viewers but wins accolades as well? We’ve asked Sarah Aubrey, Head of Original Programming for HBO Max. The streaming service behind shows like “The Pitt,” “Hacks,” “And Just Like That,” and the forthcoming “Harry Potter” series is once again evolving what audiences expect from premium television: high-quality entertainment delivered on a consistent basis.

See all episodes →