Show Notes
What happens when correcting someone you love no longer brings clarity, and may actually increase distress?
In this episode, Andrew Karesa sits down with Karen Tyrell, founder and CEO of Personalized Dementia Solutions, to explore one of the most common and misunderstood challenges in dementia care: the instinct to correct.
With more than 30 years of experience supporting families and frontline care teams, Karen explains why arguing often backfires, what anosognosia really means, and why some individuals genuinely do not believe anything is wrong. She unpacks how dementia changes insight, reasoning, and perception, and why logic alone is rarely enough.
Karen introduces the concept of therapeutic reasoning and walks through practical steps caregivers can use to reduce escalation while preserving dignity. She shares how small shifts in language can prevent repeated emotional harm, how to navigate difficult moments like repeated questions about a deceased spouse, and why medications should not be the first response to agitation.
The conversation moves beyond tactics. Karen reflects on stigma over the decades, how dementia care has evolved, and why families should build support early rather than waiting for crisis. She also speaks about her work developing dementia designation programs and creating accessible education that empowers both professionals and unpaid caregivers.
In this episode: • Why correcting someone living with dementia often increases distress • What anosognosia is and how it changes conversations • The difference between honesty and therapeutic reasoning • How to respond when someone repeatedly asks about a deceased loved one • Why agitation is communication, not defiance • When medications should and should not be considered • How to build support before burnout sets in • What preserving dignity looks like in real time
Whether you are caring for a parent, supporting a spouse, working in long-term care, or trying to understand a recent diagnosis, this episode offers grounded guidance for navigating one of dementia care’s most difficult realities.
You cannot win an argument with dementia. But you can change how you respond.
Learn more at: https://www.bluebellvillage.ca https://dementiasolutions.ca
———
Join The Village and help shape conversations like this by submitting questions to our guests: https://www.patreon.com/cw/blueBellVillage
———
Disclaimer: The information shared in this podcast is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. It should not be used to diagnose, treat, or prevent any medical condition. Always consult your physician or another qualified healthcare provider regarding any questions you may have about a medical condition or treatment. The views and opinions expressed by guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Andrew Karesa, blueBell Village Ltd., or any of its employees, contractors, or team members.
More from The Dementia Collective
What if learning about dementia started before a family ever had to face it?
What happens when someone who has spent his life rescuing people faces something he cannot rescue his own mum from? In this episode, Andrew Karesa sits down with Andrew “Reidy” Reid, longtime Bondi Rescue lifeguard, endurance athlete and dementia advocate, for an incredibly open conversation about lifeguarding, family, caregiving, grief, endurance sport, and his mum Trish’s journey with dementia. Reidy has spent more than 20 years as a lifeguard, becoming one of the familiar faces of Bondi Rescue. He has also completed more than 50 marathons, competed in Ironman triathlons, and even holds a Guinness World Record for running a marathon carrying a surfboard. But years before dementia became part of his own family, Reidy had already started using that endurance background to support dementia research through the 155-kilometre Bondi2Berry ride. Then his mum, Trish, was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease and vascular dementia. The conversation explores Reidy’s life beyond dementia, from growing up around Bondi and becoming a lifeguard to the beginnings of Bondi Rescue, extraordinary rescues, more than 50 marathons, Ironman racing, his 2:49 marathon, and the unlikely story behind his Guinness World Record marathon carrying a surfboard. In this episode: Growing up around Bondi and how Reidy became a lifeguard The real-life rescues behind Bondi Rescue What more than 20 years of lifeguarding has taught him about patience and caregiving Trish’s early signs of dementia and eventual diagnosis What it feels like to mourn someone who is still alive The emotional difficulty of visiting a parent living in a nursing home Navigating caregiving and complicated family relationships The wild story behind running a 3:17 marathon carrying a surfboard Bondi2Berry and raising money for dementia research This is a conversation about much more than Bondi Rescue. It is about what happens when the person accustomed to being the rescuer becomes a son trying to navigate something he cannot fix. Learn more at: https://www.bluebellvillage.ca ———
NOTE: This is Part 2 of 2 of our Silver Tech Summit 2.0 special. In this special episode of The Dementia Collective, Andrew Karesa sits down with seven guests at the Silver Tech Summit 2.0 in Edmonton to explore what aging well really looks like, who gets a say in shaping that future, and why older adults need to be part of the conversation. Featuring: Darlene Schindel, Founder, NurseWell Collective Dr. Martin Ferguson-Pell, Professor, Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Alberta Janice Baskin, Manager, Edmonton Regional Innovation Network Karen Murdock, Founder, Silver Longevity Business Association Jay Pritchard, President, WE Seniors Zoran Kovacevic, entrepreneur and founder of Pace Pet Chief Billy Morin, Member of Parliament for Edmonton Northwest, former Chief of Enoch Cree Nation, and Indigenous Services Critic In this episode: What “Build With Us, Not For Us” actually means Why older adults need a voice in the technologies and services created for them Why care is about more than technology Loneliness, isolation, and rebuilding community Turning research and innovation into real-world solutions Entrepreneurship and designing alongside the people you serve Indigenous entrepreneurship and culturally appropriate care for Elders Rethinking how we define and measure successful aging This special episode was filmed at and produced in conjunction with the Silver Tech Summit 2.0, hosted by WE Seniors in Edmonton, Alberta. Learn more at: https://www.bluebellvillage.ca https://silvertechsummit.ca/ https://slba.ca/ ———
NOTE: This is Part 1 of 2 of our Silver Tech Summit 2.0 special. In this special episode of The Dementia Collective, Andrew Karesa sits down with seven guests at the Silver Tech Summit 2.0 in Edmonton to explore what aging well really looks like, who gets a say in shaping that future, and why older adults need to be part of the conversation. Featuring: Darlene Schindel, Founder, NurseWell Collective Dr. Martin Ferguson-Pell, Professor, Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Alberta Janice Baskin, Manager, Edmonton Regional Innovation Network Karen Murdock, Founder, Silver Longevity Business Association Jay Pritchard, President, WE Seniors Zoran Kovacevic, entrepreneur and founder of Pace Pet Chief Billy Morin, Member of Parliament for Edmonton Northwest, former Chief of Enoch Cree Nation, and Indigenous Services Critic In this episode: What “Build With Us, Not For Us” actually means Why older adults need a voice in the technologies and services created for them Why care is about more than technology Loneliness, isolation, and rebuilding community Turning research and innovation into real-world solutions Entrepreneurship and designing alongside the people you serve Indigenous entrepreneurship and culturally appropriate care for Elders Rethinking how we define and measure successful aging This special episode was filmed at and produced in conjunction with the Silver Tech Summit 2.0, hosted by WE Seniors in Edmonton, Alberta. Learn more at: https://www.bluebellvillage.ca https://silvertechsummit.ca/ https://slba.ca/ ———
What does caregiving look like when no one sees what you’re carrying?