The Bricked Window That Frosts Itself Every February

On February 2, 1899, David Harrison, a 22-year-old junior instructor at Hadler School in Calvert Crossing, Indiana, is found dead on a narrow stone ledge outside the school. Despite the building being adequately heated, the official cause of death is recorded as exposure. Just five days later, the school board votes to brick up the window above the ledge, with no explanation provided in the minutes. This decision raises questions about the circumstances surrounding Harrison's death, particularly in light of a troubling connection to Charles Atwell, a prominent school board member who had knowledge of Harrison's undisclosed identity.

Investigator Michelle Phillips uncovers a series of anomalies in the records, including falsified inspection logs and a land transfer between Edna Harrison, David's mother, and Atwell for just one dollar, occurring shortly after the vote to seal the window. Eyewitness accounts, including those from Ida Pollock, a fellow instructor who heard a discussion and the sound of a window opening on the night of February 1, suggest that Harrison's death may not have been an accident. Instead, it points to a potential confrontation between Harrison and Atwell, who viewed Harrison's identity as a problem that needed resolution.

Phillips meticulously documents her findings, which indicate a pattern of concealment and complicity among local authorities. The narrative surrounding Harrison's death evolves from a simple ghost story into a complex tale of social dynamics, power, and the erasure of identity. While the official records remain sparse, the legend persists in Calvert Crossing, where the bricked window serves as a haunting reminder of the unresolved tragedy and the young man's life that was quietly forgotten.

The Bricked Window That Frosts Itself Every February

A cold morning, a warm classroom, and a fourteen-inch ledge where a twenty-two-year-old teacher froze to death while the stove below kept burning-locals still watch a mismatched patch of brick frost every February and call it the "ghost pane." What pushed David Harrison onto that narrow ledge in single-digit temperatures, and why did the school board brick the window five days later with no recorded reason?

In this episode, we follow the contemporaneous records and later discoveries that form the public and private trace of Harrison's last days, from maintenance logs and weather reports to an unpublished memoir and an investigator's findings-can these documents answer how a heated building yielded a dead man on an outside ledge?

Person: David Harrison Date: February 2, 1899 Location: Hadler School north wall, Calvert Crossing, Indiana Status: Cause of death recorded as "Exposure" Investigator: Michelle Phillips

- The stone ledge where Harrison was found measures fourteen inches wide. - The school’s second floor was recorded as adequately heated that winter in maintenance logs. - The Courier-Ledger published a four-sentence notice on February 3, 1899 listing Edna Harrison in Moorfield as his sole survivor. - The school board voted on February 7, 1899 to brick up the north window with a recorded vote of four to one and no reason given. - Ida Pollock wrote decades later that she heard a window open and a line go silent for eleven seconds on the night before Harrison’s body was found.

To listen to this podcast ad-free and access premium episodes, try our subscription with a 14-day free trial at obomedia.com.

© 2026 OBOMEDIA. All rights reserved. This episode and its content (audio, text, and related materials) are the exclusive property of OBOMEDIA and are protected by applicable copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, editing, or commercial use, in whole or in part, without prior written permission from OBOMEDIA is prohibited. For permissions, licensing, and business inquiries: [email protected].