The Lullaby That Ends With Nettie Vane's Name

In March 2011, Deputy Aaron Fitch of the Pickett County Sheriff's Department investigates a locked pump house in Millhaven, Tennessee, where he discovers a single sheet of paper with a lullaby ending on the name Nettie Vane. This name resonates with Wendy Doyle, a local folklore researcher who has spent years collecting oral traditions in the area. Doyle finds that the lullaby's versions, gathered from various residents, never included a name, leading her to delve into the town's history to uncover the significance of Nettie Vane.

Doyle's research reveals a troubling history tied to the Millhaven Charitable Home, which ceased operations in March 1891 under mysterious circumstances. Records indicate that 25 residents, including women and children, vanished without a trace during this time. A letter from a county commissioner suggests a cover-up of a grave incident, recommending demolition of the home and coordination with the local pastor to keep the matter confidential. The investigation uncovers that the burial records for the deceased were meticulously erased, leaving only the baptismal record of Nettie Vane, an infant baptized in extremis, as a haunting reminder of the events that transpired.

Marsha Hill, a retired records clerk, ultimately reveals her role in placing the lullaby in the pump house to draw attention to the forgotten history. She had preserved photocopies of the intake records for the charitable home, which confirmed the presence of Nettie Vane and the other residents. Despite her efforts, the official response to Doyle's findings remains muted, with no legal action taken. A small marker now stands near the pump house, acknowledging the lost lives, but the true story of what happened remains shrouded in silence, echoing through the lullaby that continues to be sung in Millhaven.

The Lullaby That Ends With Nettie Vane's Name

A bone-deep unease: a lullaby sung for over a century in a small town suddenly ends with a single, unfamiliar name - Nettie Vane - written on a dry sheet in a locked pump house. Who put that coda into a song remembered by seven people across decades, and why does the name vanish from every official record except one church register? What secret was waiting in Millhaven to be uncovered?

In this episode, the story follows the discovery at the Gabbard pump house, the county folklorist Wendy Doyle’s archive of seven lullaby versions, and the paper trail that leads to a single baptismal entry; the episode asks whether a name can be erased from official records yet persist in song.

Person: Deputy Aaron Fitch Location: Gabbard pump house Date: late March 2011 Case: lullaby ending with Nettie Vane Event: baptismal entry dated March 14, 1891

- Deputy Aaron Fitch documented three foundation gaps each narrower than a human torso at the locked pump house. - A single sheet of dry paper bearing a lullaby ending with the name Nettie Vane was found on a wooden stool. - Jogger Susan Watson heard singing from the pump house at approximately 7:15 AM on a Tuesday morning. - Folklorist Wendy Doyle had collected seven versions of the lullaby from seven sources and none ended with a name. - Saint Andrew's Episcopal Church register records Nettie Vane as "baptized in extremis" on March 14, 1891, and there is no subsequent burial or death record for her.

To listen to this podcast ad-free and access premium episodes, try our subscription with a 14-day free trial at obomedia.com.

© 2026 OBOMEDIA. All rights reserved. This episode and its content (audio, text, and related materials) are the exclusive property of OBOMEDIA and are protected by applicable copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, editing, or commercial use, in whole or in part, without prior written permission from OBOMEDIA is prohibited. For permissions, licensing, and business inquiries: [email protected].