Show Notes
Were you a “good kid” growing up—and did anyone ever ask how you were really doing on the inside?
In this eye-opening episode, Colleen O’Grady sits down with trauma therapist and author Maggie Nick to explore the hidden cost of being the “good kid.” While these kids are often praised for being easy, responsible, and well-behaved, many are silently struggling with anxiety, perfectionism, and a deep fear of disappointing others.
Maggie shares her personal story of being a lifelong people-pleaser who looked “sunshine and rainbows” on the outside but felt intense pressure and self-criticism on the inside. Through her own healing journey, she discovered that shame—not behavior—is often at the root of the good kid pattern.
This conversation helps parents understand how well-intentioned parenting, combined with a child’s temperament and sensitivity, can unintentionally create kids who disconnect from their own needs in order to feel loved and accepted.
💡 3 Key Takeaways
1. “Good” Behavior Can Hide Internal Struggles Good kids often look like they’re thriving—but many are anxious, self-critical, and disconnected from their own wants and needs. They’ve learned to focus outward—keeping others happy—while losing touch with themselves.
2. Shame Shapes Identity More Than We Realize When kids receive messages like “I expected more from you” or “What’s wrong with you,” they don’t just change behavior—they internalize it. The takeaway becomes: “Something is wrong with me.” This can follow them into adulthood.
3. Small Parenting Shifts Can Break the Cycle You don’t have to overhaul your parenting—just adjust your approach:
Move from criticism to curiosity
Allow your child to struggle without shame
Stay connected: “I don’t like the behavior, but I’m always on your side”
These small shifts help your teen stay connected to themselves—and to you.
Learn More at: https://www.instagram.com/maggiewithperspectacles?igshid=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ%3D%3D
Follow at: https://www.instagram.com/maggiewithperspectacles?igshid=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ%3D%3D Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
More from Power Your Parenting: Moms With Teens
What if the most powerful question you could ask yourself as a mom is, “What is the most courageous choice I can make right now?” Parenting teens can bring up so much fear—fear about their choices, friendships, and future. But what if instead of letting fear lead, we learned to parent with courage?
Are you teaching your teen to be themselves—or unintentionally pressuring them to become who you think they should be? As moms, we want our teens to be confident, authentic, and true to their values. But what happens when their values clash with ours? How do we help them fit in without losing themselves? And how do we stay true to ourselves while protecting our relationship with our teens?
What if the very thing you think makes you a good mom—worrying about your teen—is actually getting in the way of the relationship you want with them?
Are college applications creating more stress, anxiety, and conflict in your home than they need to?
Are you raising your teen to follow directions—or are you helping them become someone others want to follow?