The Reinsurance Podcast

How Challenger Brokers Are Winning Clients in a Soft Market | TRP #171

The Reinsurance Podcast

Show Notes

Reinsurance brokers invest heavily in analytics, cat models, and back-office systems. Almost none of it faces the client. In a softening market where cheaper reinsurance is table stakes, Ben Rose and Tom Spier break down why the broker-client relationship is the one that actually needs the technology — and why most firms have completely overlooked it.

WHAT YOU'LL LEARN: Why getting clients a cheaper deal is no longer enough to keep their business in a soft market How challenger brokers backed by private equity are forcing the big three to rethink their value proposition The structural reason brokers can't build client-facing tools in-house (and why clients don't want them to) Why the broker who meets the client where they already work will win over the one with the flashiest portal What cedents should be looking for when choosing between ten credible brokers instead of three

CONNECT WITH US: Say Hello: ⁠[email protected]⁠ Website: ⁠https://www.supercede.com⁠ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/supercedehq X: ⁠https://twitter.com/SupercedeHQ⁠ YouTube:⁠ ⁠⁠https://www.youtube.com/@SupercedeHQ⁠ RSS Feed: ⁠https://anchor.fm/s/7e741c8c/podcast/rss⁠

OUTLINE & TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 Intro01:57 How Supercede Started04:06 The Real Friction Isn't Between Broker and Underwriter05:54 The Broker Landscape: From Big Three to Top Fifteen08:13 Hard Market vs Soft Market: How Broker Value Shifts09:19 Cheap Reinsurance Is Table Stakes — Now What?10:31 What Brokers Actually Spend Their Tech Budgets On12:34 The Gap: Nothing Between Broker and Client13:56 Why In-House Portals Don't Work for Clients14:48 Analytics & the PDF Report Problem16:08 Meeting Clients Where They Are17:48 Minimising Change Management by Using Existing Workflows

More from The Reinsurance Podcast

Oct 23, 2026

Reinsurance prices are falling, but David Flandro argues that rising capital costs should give buyers pause. Howden Re’s Head of Industry Analysis and Strategic Advisory joins Ben Rose in Baden-Baden to explain why cedents need a contingency plan, how new sources of capital are reshaping the market, and what economic margins reveal about the cycle. They also explore AI’s potential to change modelling and risk trading, plus the case for rebalancing retentions, managing accumulations and preserving options ahead of 1/1.

Oct 13, 2026

Dame Susan Langley, the first Lady Mayor of the City of London in 800 years and only the third woman to hold the office, has spent a year flying round the world telling people what London’s insurance and reinsurance market actually does. Recorded at Mansion House, this is her case for why the quietest industry in finance needs to find its voice.

Sep 28, 2026

Sub-$50bn of first-half cat losses, no hurricanes last year, none so far this year, and rates heading south. Verisk's Rob Newbold boards the TRP yacht at Monte Carlo RVS to explain why reinsurance should still be braced for $171bn of insured catastrophe loss in an average year. Then he gets into what AI is actually doing to cat modelling, from globally correlated models to agents that talk to each other so humans can get on with deciding.

Sep 25, 2026

New capital is still queuing up for Lloyd's, but Argenta's Kate Tongue and Robert Flach reckon the smart money is taking its time. On board the Supercede yacht at Monte Carlo RVS, they explain three things: why investors tend to show up a year too late, why a diversified Lloyd's portfolio can rival ILS returns with less risk, and why capital cares less about a syndicate's AI than about who's parameterising it.

Sep 25, 2026

Property is softening at a sprint. Casualty is walking, and keeping one eye on US social inflation. On the TRP yacht at Monte Carlo RVS 2026, Lockton Re's Carla Moffett and Sam Sweeney explain why casualty reinsurance won't follow the rest of the market down, and why the brokers worth hiring now do much more than place the treaty.

See all episodes →