School of Practice

One Task, Many Doors: A More Effective Way to Differentiate

School of Practice

Show Notes

It’s a mistake to assume that good differentiation always means splitting students up into small groups, says Michael McDowell, an author, coach, and former teacher.

A more effective approach, he says, is to design rigorous learning routines that unite the whole class—from fast finishers to kids who need extra support—with shared strategies, structures, and thinking moves.

Think: Same surface, different deep problems, much more time in the “we do” space, and a big emphasis on high-quality classroom discussion.

In this episode of School of Practice, McDowell breaks down three low-prep differentiation strategies, explains how and when small groups fit into the picture, and makes the case for basketball over ping-pong question protocols.

Related resources:

Learn more about this episode

How to Differentiate Without Splitting Students Up

Teaching a Class With Big Ability Differences

AI Tool Demo: Differentiating Class Materials With Diffit (video)

A Starter Kit for Differentiated Instruction

4 Research-Backed Ways to Differentiate Instruction

Actionable Assessment: A Step-by-Step Guide to Responsive Teaching and Student Growth

More from School of Practice

Oct 20, 2026

It started with a student writing a joke on a sticky note: “I hope we have no tests this year.”

Oct 6, 2026

Have you ever had a lesson get derailed by a power struggle with a student? Or is there a student in your class who you got off on the wrong foot with, and you’re not sure of the best way to repair the relationship?

Sep 22, 2026

Did you know that drawing can be a learning superpower—even for students who claim they’re not good at it?

Sep 8, 2026

Everyone makes mistakes—including teachers.

Aug 25, 2026

Like a lot of other educators, Nicholas Ferroni is trying to find his way back to a time before technology was the default classroom mode. He thinks he was a better teacher back then—and kids acted more like kids.

See all episodes →