Why Lifting Weights Alone Isn't Making You Lose Fat in Perimenopause (And What Actually Works)
High Performance HealthShow Notes
In this Bitesize episode, we revisit a key conversation on why resistance training and fat loss need to be treated as two separate goals — and why blending them usually backfires. This short-form cut pulls together the core science on training for muscle/strength versus training for calorie burn, why "lifting to near failure" matters more than the weight on the bar, and a practical progression toward an unassisted pull-up. It also revisits the protein research: why menopausal women are commonly deficient, and how simply increasing protein intake can drive meaningful fat loss and lean mass gains — no calorie-cutting required.
WHAT YOU'LL LEARN
Why lifting heavy, moderate, or light doesn't matter for muscle growth — but matters enormously for building strength
How to structure your resistance training if your goal is to build or maintain muscle versus increase strength
Why treating your lifting sessions as a "calorie-burning workout" can undermine both your strength and muscle-building results
A practical progression (band-assisted reps, then eccentric lowering) for working toward an unassisted pull-up
Why menopausal-aged women are commonly deficient in protein, and what happens when protein intake alone is increased
The optimal protein target (1.6g/kg or ~0.75g/lb of body weight per day) for maximizing lean mass and fat loss
Where protein intake starts to hit diminishing returns
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Separate Your Training Goals: Muscle growth responds to sets taken near failure regardless of load; strength gains require heavier weights. Combining strength/muscle work with calorie-burning goals in the same session tends to produce lower-quality training on both fronts.
Progression Over Perfection for Pull-Ups: Band-assisted reps followed by slow eccentric (lowering) practice is an effective, movement-specific path to an unassisted pull-up — though the strength requires ongoing maintenance to keep.
Protein Is an Underused Lever: Many menopausal-aged women fall well below optimal protein intake (studies cite averages around 70g/day). Increasing protein alone — without cutting calories — has been shown to reduce body fat and increase lean mass.
Diminishing Returns Above ~0.75g/lb: Protein benefits continue to accrue above the optimal threshold but with steadily smaller returns, so hitting "close enough" still delivers most of the benefit.
BEST MOMENTS
"Lifting heavy or light really doesn't matter if you're trying to build muscle... it does matter if you're trying to increase strength."
"As soon as we start looking at our lifting programs as a way to burn more calories... that's when we start to say, 'I'm going to lift for two hours.' And those sets usually tend not to be very high quality."
"The act of increasing protein resulted in a significant gain of lean mass and a significant loss of body fat."
This episode is brought to you by Calocurb a natural appetite control supplement that helps you feel fuller, longer, without the jitters or crash of stimulant-based options. Head to calocurb.com/angela and use code ANGELA for 10% off your order.
Follow Calocurb:
Website: Calocurb.com
Instagram: @calocurb
YouTube: Calocurb
LinkedIn: Calocurb
More from High Performance Health
Can HRT actually help women in midlife build muscle and reduce visceral fat — or is lifestyle still doing most of the heavy lifting? In this conversation, Dr. Federica Amati explains what her research found, where HRT may be helpful, and why it should be seen as one tool rather than the main driver of body composition.
Dr. Alyssa Olenick on why cardio doesn't cause belly fat, what fasted training really does for fat loss, and how women in midlife should balance lifting, cardio and carbs.
How much protein do you really need to build muscle — and do women in perimenopause or menopause need more? In this conversation, Eric Helms breaks down the evidence behind some of the most common protein recommendations, including the widely quoted 1.6 grams per kilogram of body weight, when higher intakes may be useful, and why your starting point matters more than obsessing over a supposedly perfect number.
This episode is brought to you by Solaray
If you’re a woman in midlife and short on time, HIIT may be one of the most efficient ways to improve metabolic fitness and target visceral fat. In this conversation, Dr. Abbie Smith-Ryan breaks down the exact HIIT protocol her research group uses most often: one minute hard, one minute recovery, repeated for up to 10 rounds.