The Dangers of Seeing Ourselves in Artificial Intelligence (with Anil Seth and Nils Gilman)
FuturologyShow Notes
Humans are built for pattern recognition. It is the engine behind perception, emotion, and the fragile sense of self that feels so solid from the inside. For Anil Seth, this pattern-making power explains why consciousness is not a light inside but a process the brain assembles from guesses about the world. And it matters that each of us perceives that world differently.
In this episode of Futurology, Seth talks with Nils Gilman about what these differences reveal about the nature of consciousness and why they matter for the debate over artificial minds. LLMs are pattern-recognition machines of a different kind, uncanny enough to gain our sympathy but Seth argues there is no there there. Caring for conscious AI could quickly become more than a harmless curiosity. It may turn into a zero-sum game that diminishes how we treat one another long before the machines ‘wake up’ in any meaningful way, if that is even possible at all.
Anil Seth
Anil Seth’s Website: https://www.anilseth.com/
Instagram: @profanilseth https://www.instagram.com/profanilseth/
BlueSky @anilseth.bsky.social https://bsky.app/profile/anilseth.bsky.social
Twitter: https://x.com/anilkseth
An Essay Concerning Human Understanding — John Locke (Book, 1689)
How to Change Your Mind About Psychedelics — Michael Pollan (Book, 2018)
Ex Machina — Alex Garland (Film, 2014)
The Perception Census — Anil Seth et al. (Online Study, Ongoing)
The Dress — Viral Internet Illusion (Internet Phenomenon, 2015)
Müller-Lyer Illusion — Franz Carl Müller-Lyer (Visual Illusion, 1889)
Want to share suggestions or feedback?
Email [email protected]
Keep up to Date with the Berggruen Institute at:
Instagram: / berggrueninst
Twitter/X: / berggrueninst
Facebook: / berggrueninst
LinkedIn: / berggrueninst
Bluesky /futurologypod
Credits
Executive Producers: Nicolas Berggruen, Nathan Gardels, Nils Gilman, Dawn Nakagawa, and Jason Hoch.
Producers: Grant Slater, Alex Gardels, and Nathalia Ramos.
Associate Producer: Elissa Mardiney
Theme Music: Marcus Bagala.
Audio Engineer: Aaron Bastinelli
Futurology is a production of Studio B and Wavland and distributed by Realm.
More from Futurology
Hypocrisy, the old line goes, is the tribute vice pays to virtue. For eighty years, the powerful at least bothered to pay it, citing human rights, national security, and democracy as reasons for starting wars and undercutting liberties. Now the veneers have been stripped, and the next generation is not accepting business as usual.
Machines are starting to act like humans. Does that mean they’re conscious? The problem is we haven’t been able to prove how or why humans are conscious yet either. So why would we be able to offer any answers about AI?
Democracy counts people, not plants. Humans are only a sliver of life on this planet, but today, we're the only ones who get a vote. What if we gave rights to rivers and standing to trees?
Somewhere around the Enlightenment we decided that thinking was what made us human. We built our schools, careers, and sense of worth at the altar of intelligence. Now machines are passing us on that rubric, which leaves two possibilities: we were replaceable all along, or we picked the wrong standard to live by.
Relying on machines to coordinate our lives was just one step toward decentering humanity’s role in the world. Flights, banking, trade, food production... But as we start merging our actual decision-making with digital entities, exactly which pieces of humanity are we leaving behind? And how might we bring those pieces back?