TT 03-11-17: I Think My Family's Reflections Took Them | 31 Days of Halloween

TT 03-11-17: I THINK MY FAMILY'S REFLECTIONS TOOK THEM // A Brand-New Tiny Terror

Day 17 of 31 Days of Halloween 2026

You know your family better than anyone. But would you recognize them if something else took their place?

Wyatt has spent his entire life navigating the world without sight. Growing up on a secluded family farm, he's learned to recognize the people he loves by their voices, their footsteps, and even the way they smell.

So when his uncle comes downstairs one morning sounding almost—but not quite—like himself, Wyatt notices something nobody else does. Then another family member starts acting strangely. And another.

Something is happening inside the farmhouse, and Wyatt might be the only person capable of recognizing it.

Because whatever is taking his family doesn't seem to understand one very important thing.

Wyatt doesn't need to see someone to know they aren't who they claim to be.

“I Think My Family's Reflections Took Them” was written by u/Lime-Time-Live and originally published on r/NoSleep.

Tiny Terrors is a horror anthology podcast featuring strange, frightening, and occasionally inexplicable stories collected through the Tiny Terrors Scary Story Exchange.

CREDITS Written by: u/Lime-Time-Live Featuring: Mike LeBeau as Mark LeBeouf Directed by: Cole Weavers Editing By: Cole Weavers

Link to the Original Story

THANK YOU

This episode was made possible in part by the generosity of our Patreon members. Thank you to everyone who continues to support Tiny Terrors and Pulp Audio. Support Tiny Terrors and Pulp Audio on Patreon: www.patreon.com/pulpaudio

Marketed and distributed by Rusty Quill Network. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.