Girls Rewatch: Sex and the City

Sex and the City S1E12: "Oh Come All Ye Faithful" with Kay Poyer

Girls Rewatch: Sex and the City

Show Notes

Kay Poyer, the potential Fran Lebowitz of 20-something trans girls, communes with us to discuss SATC S1E12 “Oh Come All Ye Faithful.” It’s a pun once again!

Miranda dates a playwright who must cleanse himself with holy water after sinning (immediate shower after sex,) Charlotte is persecuted by the psychics of Manhattan, Carrie goes undercover in a big ol’ hat to try and meet Big’s mom at church, and Samantha exorcises her biggest demon: the man she loves has a small penis.

We share holy wisdom on how churches are the new bars for gen-z men, cigs are classic while vapes are sexless, how Charlotte and Amelia have shared clairvoyant trauma, and that truth, communication, and sisterhood are the only uppers our ladies need in a bathroom stall when talking tiny dicks.

Monarch is the personal finance app that tracks everything—accounts, investments, savings goals, and spending. Get your first year of Monarch Core for half off—just $50—with promo code GIRLSREWATCH.

Stop the guesswork and start something that works. Join Weight Watchers Core+ program for the ultimate weight loss support and better results at weightwatchers.com/GIRLSREWATCH ! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Girls Rewatch: Sex and the City

Oct 20, 2026

WE DID IT!! Our voices actually matter and manifestation works: we’re getting a Girls Revival.

Oct 13, 2026

Comedian Liza Treyger is campaigning for a second term as Girls Rewatch’s fav guest as we chat SATC S3E2, “Politically Erect.”

Oct 6, 2026

Comedian and genius behind Chanty Beluga Courtney O’Donnell helps us kick of season 3 of SATC with S3E1, “Where There’s Smoke…”

Sep 29, 2026

We have finally returned to this island we call home just in time to talk SATC S2E18, “Ex and the City” and answer the question: can we be friends with our exes?

Sep 22, 2026

Singer and guest with the most Carrie-Bradshaw-esque hair XKYLAR rounds out our LA journey chatting SATC S2E17, “Twenty-Something Girls vs. Thirty-Something Women.”

See all episodes →