When & How Does an Energy Deficit Become RED-S? Why Oversimplification Is the Problem- with Professor Louise Burke
Stronger with TimeShow Notes
🌐 Visit → https://tonyboutagy.com/ 📲 Follow us on Instagram → @tonyboutagy
If you've experienced unexplained fatigue, lost your period, or can't build muscle despite training hard - this episode will help you understand why.
Professor Louise Burke - IOC expert panel member on RED-S - explains the complexity behind low energy availability, why it's being oversimplified on social media, and why context matters more than rigid rules.
You'll learn when energy deficit becomes problematic, which body systems are affected first (and why), why stress makes everything worse, and whether the fasted training fears are actually supported by evidence.
We also discuss Professor Burke's groundbreaking Melbourne study using the only metabolic chamber in the Southern Hemisphere to compare diet-induced versus exercise-induced energy deficits.
In this Episode: The difference between low energy availability (exposure) and RED-S (syndrome)
Why energy deficits aren't always intentional (training volume, time constraints, budget)
Which body systems are affected: reproductive, bone, GI, metabolism, performance
Why some systems shut down before others (evolutionary perspective)
Stress as a major amplifier of symptoms
RED-S CAT 2 clinical diagnosis tool (requires medical expertise, not self-diagnosis)
Evolution from Female Athlete Triad to RED-S (males affected, multiple systems involved)
Cultural issues in endurance sports (Tour cyclists surviving on coffee for 7-hour rides)
Does the method of creating deficit matter? Diet vs exercise-induced
Melbourne metabolic chamber study: comparing both methods (results expected 2027)
Fasted training controversy: insufficient evidence for rigid rules
Sex differences in sensitivity to energy rhythm (confounded by stress factors)
Louise's perspective: better to exercise fasted than not exercise at all
Key insight: RED-S is far more complex than simple numerical thresholds. Context, individual variation, stress, and the method of creating deficit all matter. Oversimplified social media advice may cause more harm than good.
Melbourne Study: Professor Burke is recruiting runners, triathletes, race walkers (50k+/week) for a study comparing exercise-induced vs diet-induced energy deficit using the only metabolic chamber in the Southern Hemisphere. Results expected 2027. Contact [email protected] for recruitment information.
Go straight to the redcaps screening tool https://redcap.link/acu-agility
Topics: energy deficit, undereating, overtraining, hormones, bone health, metabolic adaptation, female athlete triad, amenorrhea, stress fractures, fasted training, sports nutrition
More from Stronger with Time
How many sets does a muscle need to grow, and how much does each extra set add? In this episode of Stronger With Time, I speak with Dr Jake Remmert about volume, frequency and effort, and what the research means for how you program for muscle growth. Jake is an exercise physiology professor at Illinois State University and a strength and physique coach. He did his PhD in Dr Mike Zourdos's Muscle Physiology Laboratory at Florida Atlantic University, is one of the primary authors of the recent meta regression on per session training volume, and co-authored the dose response analysis on weekly volume, frequency and proximity to failure with Josh Pelland and Zac Robinson. Throughout, Jake makes the case that the big rocks (effort, recoverable volume and consistency over time) matter more than the fine details.
Professor Roger Enoka is one of the world’s leading authorities on the neuromuscular system and has spent more than four decades studying how the nervous system produces movement, strength and fatigue. He is the author of Neuromechanics of Human Movement, now in its sixth edition. In this episode of Stronger With Time, we discuss why Type II muscle fibres are not simply high-threshold motor units, why light and heavy loads taken to failure can produce similar muscle growth despite differences in motor unit activity, and what can limit your ability to continue a set as you approach failure. In this episode, we discuss: What a motor unit is, and why muscle fibre type and recruitment threshold are not the same thing
How much of what we do in the gym today is genuinely new, and how much has been around for decades? In this episode of Stronger With Time, I speak with Dr Conor Heffernan about where many of the training ideas we now take for granted came from, how they changed over time, and what their history can teach us about how we train today. Conor is a historian and sociologist of sport at Ulster University whose work focuses on the history of strength training and physical culture. He is the author of The History of Physical Culture and When Fitness Went Global, and writes at Physical Culture Study.
VO2 max matters, but what else determines endurance, and how should you train for it?
Two people can have similar muscle mass and very different levels of strength. What accounts for the difference? In this episode of Stronger With Time, Tony speaks with Professor Paul Comfort, one of the world’s leading strength and conditioning researchers, about what influences strength beyond muscle size, and what that means for training. Paul is Professor of Strength and Conditioning at the University of Salford in the UK, where he leads the Master of Strength and Conditioning program. He also holds an adjunct professorship at Edith Cowan University in Western Australia. His research focuses on strength training, force production and the assessment of physical performance. In this episode, they discuss: How strength is assessed, and whether a true one-repetition maximum is as fatiguing as people think