COLD

Deceived | Hawaii | 2

COLD

Show Notes

An anonymous tip sends Nate Eaton to the beaches of Kauai in search of Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell to confront them with the question at the heart of the case: Where are the children JJ Vallow & Tylee Ryan?

And a new interview with an Idaho police officer who flew out to Hawaii offers a revealing look at the woman at the center of the case.

Want to listen ad-free and get the next episode a week early? Join the COLD Insider Club.

If you enjoy COLD/Deceived, please try these other great shows from KSL Podcasts: The Letter, Ransom, Stranger Becomes Neighbor

More from COLD

Oct 29, 2026

A promising first date. Troubling stories of an estranged wife. Then, silence. Nancy Jo Hancock recalls her evening with Charles Vallow – and a discovery months later that cast their date in a different light.

Oct 23, 2026

COLD host Dave Cawley provides a status update as the latest season draws to a close. Up next in the feed, we'll be sharing episodes of a new true crime show from KSL Podcasts. It's called Deceived: The Daybell Story, hosted by Nate Eaton of East Idaho News and produced by Ben Keubrick (lead producer of COLD season 3). Episodes of Deceived will begin appearing in the COLD podcast feed starting October 29.

Oct 21, 2026

Heidi Holmberg and Tori Riddle face their father in court, taking their power back decades after suffering abuse at Tom Jackson’s hands.

Oct 14, 2026

The waiting game begins as former East Layton police officer Tom Jackson faces new criminal charges over allegations of child sex abuse against his daughters during the 1980s. A rift emerges among Jackson’s family, with some blood relatives refusing to believe he could be capable of such terrible acts.

Oct 7, 2026

The Nancy Baird case file, kept away from prying eyes for decades, is at last released to COLD in 2023. Contained within are surprise revelations about the last people known to have seen Nancy alive.

See all episodes →