Polycurious

84. Could I Live Without Non-Monogamy?

Polycurious

Show Notes

Sarah Stroh talks about her book, Monogamaybe, her process coming to terms with her non-monogamous identity and finding a partner who supported her in that journey. We discuss how to manage and process jealousy and what agreements look like in non-monogamy when you want to be your best poly self but the reality is you’re struggling.

Resourced mentioned:

Sarah's bonus episode on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/2Knenv8lsQpqdXo57e9ZJ8?si=dEnFvBDDQmKjSQJMJRzA-g

Sarah's bonus episode on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Polycurious/posts/dating-as-new-ep-171433818

Ep.45 Poly and Pregnant with Sarah Stroh⁠ https://www.polycurious.com/podcast/ep45

Sarah's book Monogamaybe? : Honest advice on navigating relationships from monogamy to polyamory:

https://www.monogamish.me/pages/monogamaybe

When Jealousy Shows Up (Sarah's 12 min video guide):

https://www.monogamish.me/courses/hack-your-jealousy

Polycurious' Jealousy Survival Guide: https://www.polycurious.com/resources

Follow Sarah on IG: https://www.instagram.com/monogamish_me/

Subscribe to Sarah's Substack: https://substack.com/@monogamish

Follow Polycurious on IG: https://www.instagram.com/polycuriouspodcast/

Subscribe to Polycurious on Spotify⁠: https://members.spotify.com/to/polycurious

⁠Subscribe to Polycurious on Patreon⁠: https://www.patreon.com/c/Polycurious

More from Polycurious

Oct 20, 2026

Today, Ross and Eden, tantra practitioners, intimacy and relationship coaches, and community builders, share how they evolved from a very polyamorous dating life to a relationship that still leaves room for openness while honoring their nervous systems, emotional capacity, and desire to focus on each other.

Oct 13, 2026

Today I share my thoughts about The Invite, a movie about a married couple who invite their neighbors over for dinner. Things are awkward from the start, but they get even more awkward, funny, and real when an unexpected invitation to explore non-monogamy comes up.

Sep 22, 2026

Natalie Davis, author of the memoir Saying Yes: My Adventures in Polyamory, shares her journey into polyamory, from opening up her marriage in her 40s after her husband’s infidelity to navigating living with her metamours. Natalie also opens up about the end of a decade long relationship after her partner began dating someone new and could no longer offer her the kind of relationship she wanted. She reflects on what she’s learned about letting go when a relationship no longer works for you.

Sep 8, 2026

Cat, Natalie, and Joshua from The Kink Collective talk about their experience building a triad. We talk about honesty and transparency in non monogamy, especially when telling the full truth feels scary because you’re worried about your partner’s reaction, and what happens when you struggle to trust a partner who isn’t fully transparent. Natalie also shares her experience entering an established relationship, navigating Joshua’s other partners, and realizing she sometimes compared Cat to her own mom because of their significant age difference. Finally, we talk about letting go of expectations about what a relationship is “supposed” to look like and allowing their triad to develop organically.

Aug 26, 2026

When Courtney proposed opening their marriage on their 17th anniversary, their relationship was struggling. Nate was a devoted father and provider, but he had become emotionally distant. Courtney’s proposal was initially met with anger, judgment, and fears that she was trying to replace him.

See all episodes →